Excel Parking: Sheffield firm sparks complaints and a petition amid soaring profits

Watch more of our videos on ShotsTV.com 
and on Freeview 262 or Freely 565
Visit Shots! now
The firm did very well financially last year

Sheffield company Excel Parking has doubled profits amid complaints, a petition and a looming clampdown on the industry.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

The company’s ‘profit before tax’ rocketed from £2m to £4m last year, annual results show.

Excel Parking boss, Simon Renshaw-Smith, and wife Karen Gillott, company secretary, at the Barlow Hunt Ball in 2012.Excel Parking boss, Simon Renshaw-Smith, and wife Karen Gillott, company secretary, at the Barlow Hunt Ball in 2012.
Excel Parking boss, Simon Renshaw-Smith, and wife Karen Gillott, company secretary, at the Barlow Hunt Ball in 2012. | National World

The firm sends £100 demands to drivers for allegedly breaking car park rules. Last year it requested 207,220 addresses from the DVLA, up 42 per cent on the year previous.

The results also show boss Simon Renshaw-Smith was paid £240,000, plus dividends of £413,000 - a total of £653,000. Wife Karen Gillott is company secretary.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Over the last year, The Star has reported the stressfinancial hardship and misery of motorists sent disputed demands by the firm, as well as ratcheting costs and threats of debt collectors and court action.

The government has been working on a Code of Practice to crack down on the industry for five years. Announced in 2019, it was intended to cap 'fines' at £50, protect drivers from 'unfair and extortionate charges' and introduce an independent appeals service. It was shelved in 2022 when parking firms mounted a legal challenge.

Pensioner Stanley Luckhurst, aged 85, beat Excel Parking in court and launched a petition urging government to launch its long-awaited clampdown.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad
Stanley Luckhurst on the steps of the Royal Courts of Justice celebrating his win against Excel Parking. 
Stanley Luckhurst on the steps of the Royal Courts of Justice celebrating his win against Excel Parking.
Stanley Luckhurst on the steps of the Royal Courts of Justice celebrating his win against Excel Parking. | Stanley Luckhurst

He accused ministers of "dragging their feet" over a new Parking Code of Practice while a record 13m 'fines' - worth £1.3bn - are set to be issued in 2023/24 - ten years earlier than forecast.

Parking appeals expert Lynda Eagan said firms were engaging in a "feeding frenzy" in a bid to beat new curbs, with the number of 'fines' rising 16 per cent a year.

Parking champion Lynda Eagan, who claims to have helped hundreds of drivers over the last seven years, says firms are making hay before a new code of practice comes in.Parking champion Lynda Eagan, who claims to have helped hundreds of drivers over the last seven years, says firms are making hay before a new code of practice comes in.
Parking champion Lynda Eagan, who claims to have helped hundreds of drivers over the last seven years, says firms are making hay before a new code of practice comes in.

The number of requests for drivers' addresses is on track to hit 15m next year - worth up to £1.5bn. Graph: Lynda Eagan.The number of requests for drivers' addresses is on track to hit 15m next year - worth up to £1.5bn. Graph: Lynda Eagan.
The number of requests for drivers' addresses is on track to hit 15m next year - worth up to £1.5bn. Graph: Lynda Eagan. | Lynda Eagan

Last year, Sheffield MP Clive Betts, urged government to "get a move on."

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Excel Parking demands £100 for breaking its rules, twice as much as Sheffield City Council's charges.

At car parks, including Broomhill Rooftop, the firm has been criticised for densely-written sign boards that take four minutes to read, while giving drivers 10 minutes after arrival to pay.

Motorists also claim machines are often faulty and the payment app is slow, which sees them go over the deadline.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad
Gemma Rayne was hit with a £100 penalty for taking more than 10 minutes to pay.Gemma Rayne was hit with a £100 penalty for taking more than 10 minutes to pay.
Gemma Rayne was hit with a £100 penalty for taking more than 10 minutes to pay. | Other

In January 2023, the firm apologised after The Star revealed it sent dodgy £100 demands due to a fault at Broomhill. The same issue was reported 13 years ago.

In the same month, Jane Walker received a £100 demand for 'non-payment'.

She fought it all the way and in February 2024 was victorious in court. A judge dismissed the case against her due to shoddy evidence.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad
Mrs Walker cut short a holiday to attend court.Mrs Walker cut short a holiday to attend court.
Mrs Walker cut short a holiday to attend court. | National World

She criticised Excel Parking for “contempt of the court process” and accused the company of “wasting public time and expense” after the “farce” at Sheffield’s County Court.

At Berkeley Centre on Ecclesall Road, Excel had a secret 10-minute time rule until it was highlighted by The Star and scrapped. The company has since been removed from the site and complaints have halted.

At Newcastle Avenue in Worksop, disabled pensioner Derrick Walker received a £100 demand after being given zero minutes to buy a parking ticket.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad
Derrick Walker received a letter from Sheffield-based Excel Parking stating he had failed to pay in the time allowed. It added: ‘The Maximum period allowed at this site is 0 minutes’.
Derrick Walker received a letter from Sheffield-based Excel Parking stating he had failed to pay in the time allowed. It added: ‘The Maximum period allowed at this site is 0 minutes’.
Derrick Walker received a letter from Sheffield-based Excel Parking stating he had failed to pay in the time allowed. It added: ‘The Maximum period allowed at this site is 0 minutes’. | Other

It came after widow Sandra White said she was selling her car after receiving three 'fines' in a week from the same site - two for breaching the five-minute time rule which she was unaware of. Her appeals were rejected.

Christine Ayres with letters from Vehicle Control Services.Christine Ayres with letters from Vehicle Control Services.
Christine Ayres with letters from Vehicle Control Services.

In another case, Excel subsidiary VCS ignored the pleas of the landowner it was working for - Broomhill Methodist Church - and refused to cancel a penalty issued to choir singer Christine Ayres.

As well as Stanley Luckhurst, Excel has taken drivers to court for mis-typing a registration number and - in a case brought by VCS - stopping for 30 seconds in a medical emergency. It lost them both.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad
Kamlesh Patel represented himself at Leicester County Court where a judge dismissed the case against him and refused parking firm VCS the right to appeal.
Kamlesh Patel represented himself at Leicester County Court where a judge dismissed the case against him and refused parking firm VCS the right to appeal.
Kamlesh Patel represented himself at Leicester County Court where a judge dismissed the case against him and refused parking firm VCS the right to appeal. | other

Karen Bennett made a keying error while paying £3.20 on the Sheffield company’s payment app at a car park in Halifax. 

Excel Parking wanted £500 from Karen Bennett after she made a keying error while paying £3.20 on its payment app. 

Excel Parking wanted £500 from Karen Bennett after she made a keying error while paying £3.20 on its payment app.
Excel Parking wanted £500 from Karen Bennett after she made a keying error while paying £3.20 on its payment app. | other

Excel said she had broken its rules and the penalty was £100. The amount jumped to £170 while she unsuccessfully appealed. Eventually it climbed to £280 amid threats of debt collectors and legal action.

Finally, in a last ditch attempt to avoid a trial, the firm said it would accept £200 as settlement. But if she refused it would 'bring this letter to the court’s attention and seek further costs of £220' - a total of £500.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

A judge at Bradford County Court dismissed the case and denied Excel’s request for costs stating they were disproportionate and it had failed to justify them.

Excel Parking is a member of trade body International Parking Community, which runs the Independent Appeals Service. The IPC is funded by parking firms including Excel and Excel boss, Simon Renshaw-Smith sits on the IPC steering committee.

Excel Parking is based on Europa View in Tinsley. A spokesperson said they supported the new single Code of Practice.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

They added: "The vast majority of parking operators follow an existing Code of Practice with either the IPC (the International Parking Community) or the BPA (British Parking Association) and have processes in place for motorists to appeal should they consider that a parking charge has been issued unfairly.

"The new unified Code will adopt many elements of the existing codes which will further improve consistency and clarity for motorists, landowners and parking operators.

"We understand that parking can be an emotive subject, not only for those who receive a parking charge but also for motorists who are negatively impacted by those who park irresponsibly as well as those who blatantly abuse private land.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

"A recent survey undertaken by our Trade Association, the IPC, found that 99.77 per cent of motorists comply with private parking."

A DLUHC spokesperson said: "We are carefully considering the responses to our recent Call for Evidence on the Private Parking Code of Practice and next steps will be set out in due course. "The government continues to work with the industry and consumer groups to reissue the code as quickly as possible."

Comment Guidelines

National World encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.