It's a question that people could probably argue about forever.
But we went out to ask people on the streets of Sheffield for their choice, and also put the same question to some of The Star’s writers.
The result has been an eclectic selection of 17 nominations, dating right back from iconic shows as far back as the 1960s, right up to high profile performances which had the city dancing in recent years
And one global superstar appears twice on the list.
The selections range all the way from international superstars to local heroes of the Sheffield music scene, and are listed in the gallery below.

9. Arctic Monkeys, Hillsborough Park
Rob Graveley, from Nether Edge, said: "I think it might have been The Arctic Monkeys at Hillsborough Park the other year. Probably because, well, it was a bog event. It was the Arctic Monkey's coming back home. It was a good gig, I enjoyed that. I went with the family and they all enjoyed it.. | National World Photo: Dean Atkins

10. Bruce Springsteen, Bramall Lane, 1988
Alan Smith, from Wincobank, was among the audience when Bruce Spingsteen playing to 88,000 fans across two consecutive sell-out shows at Sheffield United’s stadium,in July 1988, at Bramall Lane. He said: "Obviously Springsteen was at his peak." Photo: Sheffield Newspapers Ltd

11. Tina Turner. Mojo Club
Dave Drabble, from Mosborough felt the best gig he had seen in Sheffield was Ike and Tina Turner, at the old Mojo club in the 1960s. He said: "It goes back a long way, Stringfellow's place. It was a totally tremendous night. That was Ike and Tina Turner Review. Photo: Paul Chappels Photo: PAUL CHAPPELLS

12. Beatles
Robert Swanson opted for an early Beatles gig he saw, in the early 60s, at Sheffield University, before they had hit the big time. He said: "Without doubt, the Beatles at the students union. That was in 1962, I would think." He said his biggest memory was of the crowds, and the girls and everyone going mad. "That was before they become really famous." he added. "And they came back to Sheffield a year later and we saw them again, and it was absolutely massive, and I had by picture taken by the Sheffield Star." | Beatles at Sheffield University Photo: ©Sheffield Newspapers Ltd


