It's a question that people could probably argue about forever.
But we went out to ask people on the streets of Sheffield for their choice, and also put the same question to some of The Star’s writers.
The result has been an eclectic selection of 17 nominations, dating right back from iconic shows as far back as the 1960s, right up to high profile performances which had the city dancing in recent years
And one global superstar appears twice on the list.
The selections range all the way from international superstars to local heroes of the Sheffield music scene, and are listed in the gallery below.

5. Theory of a Dead Man
Amy Widdrington, from Woodhouse, said: "I watched Theory of a Dead Man, in The Leadmill. She said: "They were fun, and they got the audience interacting. It was a good night.". Picture shows The Leadmill, where the show took place | National Worlld

6. The Waterboys
Christian Robinson, of Crosspool, thought the best gig he's seen in the city was The Waterboys at Sheffield City Hall in the 1980s. He said: "I was about 15. They were fantastic live. The best song was probably Fisherman's Blues, because the whole place went crazy." Pictured is Waterboys singer Mike Scott. PIcture: Mike Wade, National World | National World

7. Tina Turner
Shirley Turner told The Star she thought Tina Turner was the best gig she's seen in Sheffield, at Sheffield Arena. She said Simply the Best was the best song she performed. Picture: Paul Chappells, National World | National World

8. Bryan Adams
Shirley Tucker, of Sheffield, also chose Bryan Adams at Sheffield Arena, adding his song Summer of 69 had been the most popular on the night. Picture: Steve Taylor, National World | National World


