It's a question that people could probably argue about forever.
But we went out to ask people on the streets of Sheffield for their choice, and also put the same question to some of The Star’s writers.
The result has been an eclectic selection of 17 nominations, dating right back from iconic shows as far back as the 1960s, right up to high profile performances which had the city dancing in recent years
And one global superstar appears twice on the list.
The selections range all the way from international superstars to local heroes of the Sheffield music scene, and are listed in the gallery below.

13. Andre Rieu at Sheffield Arena
Alex Oprita, from Sheffield city centre, opted for the violinist Andre Rieu, at Sheffield Arena. He said: "I can't remember when it was exactly, but it was the best one I've ever seen,. The type of music that he played was just a bit extraordinary. It was a mixture of classical music, but at the same time it was newer." | National World

14. The Who, Sheffield University
Alan Smith, of Wincobank, had a second nomination for the best gig he's ever seen in Sheffield - The Who at Sheffield University students union in around 1970. He said: "Obviously The Who were at their peak." The picture here shows Pete Townshend and Roger Daltrey with a plaque to a gig at Leeds during the same era | National World

15. Sugababes
The Star's Chloe Aslett thought Sugababes, at Tramlines, was the best gig she had seen in Sheffield. "it was loads better than I expected," she said. "Everyone was dancing." | Press Association

16. Black Sabbath
The Star's David Walsh rated Black Sabbath at Sheffield Arena as the best show he'd seen in Sheffield. He said: "It was without Ozzy Osborn, but it was great." | PRESS ASSOCIATION


