It's a question that people could probably argue about forever.
But we went out to ask people on the streets of Sheffield for their choice, and also put the same question to some of The Star’s writers.
The result has been an eclectic selection of 17 nominations, dating right back from iconic shows as far back as the 1960s, right up to high profile performances which had the city dancing in recent years
And one global superstar appears twice on the list.
The selections range all the way from international superstars to local heroes of the Sheffield music scene, and are listed in the gallery below.

17. Self Esteem
The Star's Sarah Marshall said the best gig she had seen in Sheffield was Self Esteem at the Get Together Festival at the university in 2021. She said the singer wore a Sheffield Wednesday shirt for the show. | National World

18. Stone Roses
The Star's David Kessen rated the Stone Roses at the Leadmill in 1988 as the best show he'd seen in Sheffield. He said: "They were supporting the Jack Rubies, so they were a complete surprise at the time, and few had seen them before.", Press Association picture shows Stone Roses singer Ian Brown | Press Association


