South Yorkshire’s Police and Crime Commissioner claims 99.9 per cent of children do not carry knives

South Yorkshire’s Police and Crime Commissioner is calling for ‘a sense of proportion’ over knife crime fears – claiming 99.9 per cent of children do not carry blades.

Friday, 8th March 2019, 7:36 am
Updated Friday, 8th March 2019, 7:38 am
Dr Alan Billings

Knife crime was described by one chief constable this week as a ‘national emergency’ and there was a top level summit between police chiefs and the Home Secretary following a spate of fatal stabbings, including the deaths of two teenagers in Manchester and London last weekend. 

There were eight fatal stabbings in South Yorkshire last year, but police figures show a 12 per cent reduction.

Dr Alan Billings

Sign up to our daily newsletter

The i newsletter cut through the noise

South Yorkshire PCC, Dr Alan Billings, said: “If you were a visitor from Mars watching British television you might think that every child in the country is either carrying a knife or being threatened by someone who is - on a daily basis.

“This is the impression that is being given as a result of recent horrific incidents in London and Manchester.

“We need to steady up a bit and get a sense of proportion.

“So, let’s be clear –  99.9 per cent  of children and young people across the country do not have knives on them.

“The vast majority of young people are not so foolish as to think it would offer them ‘protection’ or would impress any of their friends.”

CRIME: Sheffield dealer jailed after police find drugs worth £20,000 He added: “They do know, however, that they would run the risk of being hurt themselves if they did carry a knife and would soon find themselves in trouble with the law. That’s what all the evidence tells them.

“But the constant talk of crisis will create serious anxieties for young people if it carries on.”

Dr Billings continued: “Those of us with longer memories will remember that we have been here before.

“When I was young there were switchblades. Gangs used them in the United States. They appeared in films such as Rebel Without a Cause and West Side Story. They were known here as flick knives – the blade was in the handle and came out automatically when a button was pressed. They were associated with Teddy Boys. There were similar media frenzies.

“But eventually, people pulled themselves together and took effective action.

“In South Yorkshire I think we have a measured approach that is making a difference. We have a plan. Crucial to it is the police working with the local authorities, schools and other


“Next year we are putting more police officers on the streets – for the first time since 2010.

“We recognise the part drugs have played in much of the increased violence – so drug gangs are being identified and disrupted. Stop and search will be used, though in a proportionate way.

“We are informing young people in the schools, making it clear to them that if they carry a knife there will be consequences – from the risk of being stopped by the police to the risk of being harmed.

“Last year, despite some high profile cases, knife incidents in South Yorkshire fell.

“We need to keep that downward trend with this plan. It tackles root causes - but without frightening young people to death.”