Sheffield green belt: Government says over 30,000 homes on brownfield sites 'not enough'

Over 30,000 homes are set to be built on brownfield sites in Sheffield - but it is not enough to meet government quotas.

Sheffield City Council says it has put forward plans for 25,572 homes on brownfield sites and estimates a further 7,675 dwellings will be built on plots expected to become available in coming years, the majority of which will be brownfield.

Michelle Dewire of Beaver Drive, Handsworth, is fighting plans for 868 green belt homes behind her house.placeholder image
Michelle Dewire of Beaver Drive, Handsworth, is fighting plans for 868 green belt homes behind her house. | Nw

It means “all developable and available land for housing within the existing urban areas - public and private - has already been identified” and “all options to build within non-green belt areas have been fully explored, or maximised.”

But it is not enough to meet a shortfall identified by government inspectors, which wants 38,012 new homes by 2039.

The old Norton Aerodrome in Sheffield. The site, which is earmarked for housing by Sheffield City Council, could also temporarily house parks service equipmentplaceholder image
The old Norton Aerodrome in Sheffield. The site, which is earmarked for housing by Sheffield City Council, could also temporarily house parks service equipment

It is this shortfall that has led to plans for 3,529 houses, 130 acres for business, three schools and two graveyards on 14 green belt sites.

A spokesperson for Sheffield City Council said: “The inspectors state that, having considered the council’s green belt and site appraisal work, exceptional circumstances could exist in principle to warrant the release of some further green belt land for housing.

Green belt land Land between Lodge Moor Road and Redmires Conduit is earmarked for 258 homesplaceholder image
Green belt land Land between Lodge Moor Road and Redmires Conduit is earmarked for 258 homes | Google

“Our surveys and assessments support the inspectors’ conclusions.

“We consider that all developable and available land for housing within the existing urban areas - public and private - has already been identified.

“The Draft Sheffield Plan, submitted to the government in October 2023, already identifies capacity for approximately 25,572 homes on brownfield sites, including 270 homes on the former Norton Aerodrome, a brownfield site in the green belt.

“This represents 89 per cent of the total identified supply.

“We have also estimated that 7,675 dwellings will be built on ‘windfall sites’ - sites not specifically allocated in the Plan - which are expected to come forward in the period up to 2039 - the majority of these are also expected to be on brownfield sites. The windfall assumption has already been accepted by the inspectors.

“We have identified some additional brownfield employment land within the urban areas but not enough to meet the shortfall identified by the inspectors”

If given the go-ahead, it would be the biggest loss of green belt land ever, some 809 acres, or 3.6 per cent of the total area of 22,390 acres.

The proposals include a secondary school (12 acres) and SEND school (five acres) on land to the south of Wheel Lane/Land between Creswick Avenue and Yew Lane in Grenoside.placeholder image
The proposals include a secondary school (12 acres) and SEND school (five acres) on land to the south of Wheel Lane/Land between Creswick Avenue and Yew Lane in Grenoside. | Google

The news has been met with shock and dismay from residents in affected areas, especially Handsworth which is earmarked for 1,638 houses on two sites, 49 acres for employment use, a secondary school and graveyard.

Grenoside could see 945 homes across three sites, a secondary school, a special needs school and graveyard, all in green belt.

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice