Barnsley man ran out of house wielding two knives before fatal stabbing, Sheffield Crown Court told

A man is said to have run out of his home with two knives to attack a dad who ‘posed no threat’ after an argument over anti-social behaviour, a court heard.

Alan Sutton died on the side of a road in September 2024 after being stabbed twice in what was described as an intentional attack, jurors were told at Sheffield Crown Court yesterday (February 2).

Callum Strachan has been accused of the 41-year-old dad’s murder.

He denies the charge.

Prosecuting barrister Sharon Beattie KC told the court that Strachan had ongoing issues with his neighbours at the time of Mr Sutton’s death.

23-year-old Strachan had been accused of anti-social behaviour by neighbours after moving to Burton Road, in the Monk Bretton area of Barnsley, with the court told that he had threatened others who lived on the street on multiple occasions.

Alan Sutton, aged 41, died after he was stabbed  wounds on the afternoon of Sunday, September 1, 2024. A man accused of his murder, 23-year-old Callum Strachan, is now standing trial. placeholder image
Alan Sutton, aged 41, died after he was stabbed wounds on the afternoon of Sunday, September 1, 2024. A man accused of his murder, 23-year-old Callum Strachan, is now standing trial. | Submit

One woman, after seeking council advice, began keeping a log of Strachan’s behaviour, the court heard, which included claims that he was spotted on the street with a knife and a threat to stab her young, autistic daughter.

However, after what the prosecution calls a ‘pattern of anti-social behaviour’, things heated up on Sunday, September 1, 2024.

Witnesses claimed that Strachan was behaving erratically, jurors heard, before making threats to other people on the street shortly before 4pm.

A worried neighbour called her friend and brother, and the two of them - as well as Mr Sutton, who happened to be with them at the time - headed to the street to see what was going on, the prosecution said.

“Once there, there was clearly a confrontation between Strachan, and the two others - it is partly captured on CCTV,” the prosecutor told jurors.

“Also what was captured was Alan Sutton and he can be seen, along with other people, standing watching - he doesn’t do anything.”

Ms Beattie continued to explain that CCTV showed Strachan throwing a bicycle at the men, with footage shown to jurors of the arrival of the three men.

In court, Strachan - who appeared in a white shirt and tie - muttered to himself in the docks as the footage was shown.

The prosecutor said that within the space of two minutes the confrontation calmed down and Strachan went back into his home.

Mr Sutton and the two other men turned to leave and walk away, with the prosecutor describing them as ‘appearing calm’ as they left.

“Alan Sutton went to walk off, but as he did so Callum Strachan ran from his house, but now he was armed with two knives” Ms Beattie added.

“He ran straight out to Mr Sutton and stabbed him twice, with both knives.”

Jurors were told that Mr Sutton - who was a father - was stabbed in both the chest and the neck, with the incident being captured on the dashcam of a passing taxi.

The footage of the incident was shown in court.

“This was no accident,” Ms Beattie told jurors, describing it as a fatal attack on a man ‘who posed no threat’.

She explained that while Mr Sutton had been carrying a grey extendable baton that was ‘tucked up his sleeve’, he was not seen at any point trying to take it out.

It was also explained to jurors that a man was seen hitting on the windows of what appeared to be Strachan’s house, however witnesses who reported this also reported seeing a body on the road - suggesting that it occurred after Mr Sutton had already been stabbed, the prosecutor surmised.

Ms Beattie said that following the incident, Strachan ran back to his house and attempted to hide the knives, which were later discovered by police in kitchen drawers with evidence of Mr Sutton’s DNA.

He then fled his home, jurors were told, meeting with his girlfriend before waving down a police car.

“More or less straight away he embarked on a scheme to say he was the victim of an attack,” Ms Beattie continued.

“Callum Strachan cast himself as both a victim, and as someone who was scared for his pregnant girlfriend.

“He made no mention of the stabbing and appeared collected.”

Emergency services arrived, however Alan Sutton - who was known by friends and family as Algi - passed away.

The trial continues.

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice