Well-known Sheffield city centre pub ordered to ditch beer terrace ‘chalets’ over safety and view
Maggie May’s put outdoor seating in place during the pandemic lockdown
For years they have been a familiar site for drinkers in Sheffield city centre.
But now last orders look set to be called on the robust, wooden chalets which have been used by visitors to the well known Sheffield bar Maggie May’s, on Trippet Lane, since the pandemic.


The outdoor seating area was put in place while the city was dealing with the 2020 coronavirus epidemic, with some of the cost coming from Government grants designed to help businesses survive.
But now, Sheffield Council is ordering bosses to get rid of it, because of concerns over its safety and how it looks, some six years on from lockdown.
In a delegated decision made by council officers, bosses at the pub have been refused planning permission to keep the facility, and an enforcement order is being issued to order its removal.
Gary Sinclair, of ThatOne Ltd, who put the planning application together for Maggie May’s, said in the application: “The area benefits from artificial turf and is well maintained by our staff. It is a welcome addition to the outside 'cafe culture' the City Centre actively promotes for the hospitality industry.


He told council officials that the four Swiss style chalets were positioned on what was a four- car parking bay outside Maggie May’s on Trippet Lane, that they were modelled on the type used for the Fargate Christmas markets.
He added: “They form the main attraction of our outside beer garden but cannot practically be removed at the end of the day. Our facility also features artificial grass running the full length of the 'garden'....and weighted barrier protection on the road side next to the cycle lane.
“The 'garden' area provides an outside communal area for customers promoting a cosmopolitan feel in line with other pedestrian areas within the city centre.”
But Sheffield Council turned the request down, after officials raised concerns about how it looked, in front of what is a Grade II listed heritage building, and because of highways safety concerns.


A council officer’s report, used in making the decision, stated the chalets had originally been put in place under a temporary pavement café licence introduced by the Business and Planning Act 2020 in response to the pandemic to help hospitality businesses trade outdoors, and requiring the use of removable furniture.
The said the pub was part of what was once The Anglo Works, a former cutlery and silversmiths works, built circa 1800, and part of a conservation area.
The report stated: “The proposal would not preserve or enhance the character of the conservation area or the setting of the Grade II Listed Anglo Works, and would harm the significance of these heritage assets. “
The report also raised concerns over the barriers used to separate the chalets from the road, warning: “Sitting the seating area in a live carriageway requires an appropriate level of highway protection to be provided to avoid conflict between users.”
It added: “The proposal relies upon highway protection barriers which the Council's Network Management Team has confirmed are intended only for temporary deployment and have not been demonstrated to provide an appropriate permanent means of protecting users of the seating area from adjacent vehicular traffic.
“In the absence of an appropriate permanent highway protection solution, the Local Planning Authority cannot be satisfied that the development would provide a safe environment for users of the seating area or maintain safe operation of the adjoining highway throughout the lifetime of the development.”
- RELATED: Sheffield pub re-opening plans spark green space access row
- RELATED: Cafe blasts “ridiculous” licencing requirements taking away outdoor seating area
- RELATED: 'Critical' food donation levels for Yorkshire food banks
- RELATED: Sheffield city centre businesses ‘in crisis’ as they take VAT drop campaign to Mayor
