Victorian pub set to be lost, as plans for new use for Sheffield site approved
End of the line for historic pub under new plans
A well known Sheffield pub looks set to be lost, after Sheffield Council approved plans to convert it into a children’s nursery.
Sheffield Council has now approved a planning application which seeks to make the change at the Mason’s Arms, Carson Road, Crookes.


Said to date back to the 1870s, The Mason’s was refurbished as a pub as recently as 2020, and was running as a pub - restaurant in 2025.
But in March, Carlette Sarahyreh submitted a planning application asking to convert the venue, with proposals for a nursery complete with children’s activity areas and administration officers replacing the bar and pool table, and an outside activities area replacing the beer garden.
Today, the council has approved the application, subject to a number of conditions involving issues like delivery times, opening times and disabled access arrangements.
It comes after Sheffield Council officers wrote a report backing the plans.
They said there had been four letters of objection to the scheme, raising concerns over issues lack of parking spaces in an already busy area.. But the report said the scheme would not result in unacceptable highway safety impacts.


Officers added in their report: “The submission details that it is anticipated that the majority of carers will walk, bus, cycle and use nearby short stay parking to drop off.
“The site is situated within a really high walkable catchment, also with excellent public transport links, this would reduce the demand for parking and traffic generation associated with the use. “
A planning statement accompanying the application stated: “The proposal seeks permission for the conversion and internal reconfiguration of the existing building to provide a nursery facility accommodating approximately 65 children, with associated staff facilities, outdoor play space and limited on-site drop-off parking.
“The proposed nursery will operate between 7am and 7pm Monday to Friday, 52 weeks per year, closing only on Christmas Day, Boxing Day and New Year’s Day.
“The development will provide an important community facility serving local families, supporting childcare provision in the Crookes area while making productive use of an existing building.”
The new venue would employ 15 staff, according to the application.
Last year, the pub was being run as a pub and burger restaurant, by businessman Mitchell Hinchliffe, having been opened in that guise in October 2024. However it subsequently closed.
One of the rooms had been converted into a restaurant area, with the second room remaining a more traditional bar, with darts board and pool table.
Prior to that, it had been given a makeover by its then new landlords Brandon Hoult and Jamie Tuxford, in 2020, shortly before the coronavirus lockdown that year.
It is one of a number of pubs in Crookes.
