Being so spoilt for choice means it’s often easier to plump for the same place every time, whether it’s fine dining at the excellent JÖRO or Rafters, street food from one of the fantastic food halls, or your favourite local Italian.
But there are lots of hidden gems out there which you really need to try if you haven’t already.
With that in mind, we’ve put together a list of some of the city’s best independent restaurants which perhaps don’t always get the recognition they deserve, despite excellent reviews from those in the know.
We’ve left out some brilliant restaurants within Sheffield because we feel they’re already so well known.
How many of these places have you eaten at, is your favourite on the list and which other restaurants do you feel we should have included?

9. Butta La Pasta
Stephen Ogden gave up his job as a children's nurse to open this small but perfectly formed Italian restaurant on London Road, Sheffield, in 2018. The quality of the ingredients and the skill with which they are cooked quickly made it a word-of-mouth hit. It has a 4.8/5 rating from more than 100 Google reviews, with one diner commenting that the excellent freshly-made pasta was 'up there with any I've had in Italy'. | Google Photo: Google

10. Pellizco
Pellizco began life operating out of an orange trailer in 2020. People couldn't get enough of the Mexican-inspired street food, and in December 2022, it opened as a restaurant at Dyson Place, off Sharrow Vale Road, where its tacos, quesadillas and other Latin American classics have continued to go down a storm. It has a 4.8/5 star rating from nearly 200 Google reviews, with one fan calling it the 'best Mexican food I've ever had'. Photo: Pellizco | Pellizco Photo: Pellizco

11. IMG_4446.jpeg
Rosmarino opened on Abbeydale Road, Sheffield, in April 2022, and in the two-and-a-half years since then has established itself as one of the city's best-loved Italian restaurants. It has a 4.9/5 star rating from 70 reviews, with one diner praising the 'delicious fresh balanced dishes made from high quality ingedients' at what they called 'the best Italian restaurant I've been to'. | Rosmarino Photo: Rosmarino

