Being so spoilt for choice means it’s often easier to plump for the same place every time, whether it’s fine dining at the excellent JÖRO or Rafters, street food from one of the fantastic food halls, or your favourite local Italian.
But there are lots of hidden gems out there which you really need to try if you haven’t already.
With that in mind, we’ve put together a list of some of the city’s best independent restaurants which perhaps don’t always get the recognition they deserve, despite excellent reviews from those in the know.
We’ve left out some brilliant restaurants within Sheffield because we feel they’re already so well known.
How many of these places have you eaten at, is your favourite on the list and which other restaurants do you feel we should have included?

5. Frérot
Frérot is the best thing about Sheffield city centre's new Cambridge Street Collective food hall, serving Michelin quality food at affordable prices in a relaxed setting. It's from the brothers behind the popular Juke & Loe restaurant, first on Ecclesall Road and then at the Milestone in Kelham Island, so the quality of the cooking should come as no surprise. It has a 4.9/5 rating from 37 reviews, with one diner praising it as 'unbelievable'. | National World Photo: National World

6. Kia's Pastaria
Sheffield has some fabulous Italian restaurants, including Domo, in Kelham Island, and Grazie, in the city centre, but Kia's Pastaria, on Abbeydale Road, is right up there with the best. The attention to detail at this charming little family-run restaurant is spot on. It has a 4.8/5 rating from nearly 500 Google reviews, with one diner praising the 'outstanding' food and 'superb' service, and calling it 'one of the best restaurants in Sheffield'. | Google Photo: Google

7. Yutu
Yutu, on Eyre Street, in Sheffield city centre, has an almost perfect 4.9/5 star rating from 70 Google reviews. Those in the know rave about the quality of the food at the Japanese and Korean fusion restaurant, including the sushi, the gyoza and the katsu curry, as well as the reasonable prices. One person wrote: "The reviews don’t lie - the food is INCREDIBLE." | Google Photo: Google

8. Paesani
Paesani deli and pizzeria in Crookes only opened in July 2021 but has quickly established itself as a firm favourite with locals. It has a 4.8/5 star rating from more than 400 reviews, with one person declaring that it serves 'the BEST pizza in Sheffield hands down!'. | Chris Etchells Photo: Chris Etchells

