"Like many Sheffielders I want to be proud of what our city has to offer, not quibbling over street preachers"

A Star reader has criticised a city councillor’s call to tackle ‘noisy’ street preachers.

Earlier this month, Councillor Laura Moynahan raised concerns about loud street preachers in Sheffield city centre during a discussion about the public spaces protection order (PSPO) covering anti-social behaviour in the city centre.

She told Sheffield City Council’s communities, parks and leisure policy committee on November 3, that the noise now meant that people avoided sitting in places like The Moor.

She added at the time: “I witnessed it on The Moor where the decibels were ridiculous. I went to the market to buy some fish and there were people sitting having their lunch on The Moor on those benches and they actually got up and walked away.

“They didn’t want to sit there through that noise.”

A Star reader has argued that debates around street preachers are distracting the council from more important matters, such as ‘revitalising the city centre’. placeholder image
A Star reader has argued that debates around street preachers are distracting the council from more important matters, such as ‘revitalising the city centre’. | nw

Council director of customer experience and communities Tom Smith replied that the council already has powers on noise nuisance that it can use. He said that bringing in new rules needs careful consideration because it could have an impact on events and entertainment that the council does want to run.

However, now Star reader B Wiles has written in calling for the council to instead focus on more pressing matters, defending street preachers’ freedom of expression.

They wrote: “So Councillor Moynahan wants to curb the ‘noisy’ street preachers in the city centre.

“Surely if she considers them too noisy, then the same must also apply to the buskers, who likewise use mics and speakers.

“Whilst some of them sound great (and I also thoroughly welcome the various choirs, musicians and dancers as well) others sound like the worst kind of karaoke bar.

“It takes all sorts, and together they bring a vibe and energy to the city.

“Perhaps the city ambassador’s might quietly request any groups or individuals making excessive noise to ‘turn it down a notch’.

“Hopefully, Tom Smith and his committee will get on with the more pressing issue of revitalising the city centre.

“While plaudits are due for Leah’s Yard and Pound’s Park, we still need more events, improvements to (the perception of) safety.

“These include lighting on Chapel Walk, continued action over threatening beggars and possibly initiatives such as cheaper (weekend/evening?) parking in the lead-up to Christmas and the temporary use of parts of the John Lewis building.

“Like so many Sheffielders I want once again to be proud of what our city centre has to offer, not quibbling over street preachers.”

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice