STOS Theatre’s Nativity! The Musical is a must-see festive treat at the Lyceum in Sheffield

A packed, playful production with strong performances, big laughs and a touching turn from its young cast makes for a winning night at the theatre.

It might still be November but Sheffield city centre looks truly festive now the Christmas lights are on. The markets were the perfect excuse to stop for a drink at the Alpine Bar on our way to the Lyceum so see one of the most popular festive shows.

Young Sheffield superstars take to the stage for Nativity! The Musicalplaceholder image
Young Sheffield superstars take to the stage for Nativity! The Musical | Phoebe Roe-Parkin of Roie-Parkin Creative

As we got into the Lyceum children were pouring over the cast poster - picking out their friends who were performing in STOS Theatre Company’s Nativity! The Musical.

You can't beat a silly visual gag - including cast members popping out of boxesplaceholder image
You can't beat a silly visual gag - including cast members popping out of boxes | Phoebe Roe-Parkin of Roie-Parkin Creative

Based on Debbie Isitt’s film, the musical turns a primary school nativity into a battle for a five-star review. St Bernadette’s teacher Paul Maddens is up against rival Gordon Shakespeare, and a loose remark about a Hollywood producer coming to watch soon has the whole school believing its Christmas show could end up on the big screen.

Sam Widdowson as Mr Poppy is a reliable source of mischief with a succession of ridiculous Christmas jumpers and, at one point, a pair of pants worn as a hat before they were flung into the wings like a Frisbee. Cast members pop out of boxes in a show that takes obvious delight in a silly visual gag.

STOS offers the perfect festive treat with Nativityplaceholder image
STOS offers the perfect festive treat with Nativity | Phoebe Roe-Parkin of Roie-Parkin Creative

Richard Granger is just as impressive as Maddens. His mounting exasperation gives Widdowson something to play against, and the more seriously Maddens takes the situation, the funnier it becomes.

Some of the staging was harder to follow from the upper circle. When Charlotte Waxman’s Jennifer appeared at the top of the stairs at the back of the stage, it sometimes took a while to work out who was there. The young cast member descending from the rooftop as the infamous star would’ve likely been our favourite moment but cheers of delight from the audience below us reached us a while before the star came into view.

Nativity! brings Christmas joy but also poignant momentsplaceholder image
Nativity! brings Christmas joy but also poignant moments | Phoebe Roe-Parkin of Roie-Parkin Creative

Evie-Rose Drake, as Katelyn, is clearly one to watch with a powerful singing voice. However, Ollie, played by Dexter Hood gave me both my biggest laugh and the moment that made me tear up. I loved his rap and it was his mum and dad not coming to watch unless he plays Joseph that brought tears to my eyes. Hearing that in a child’s voice made the line land. For all the adults’ talk of Hollywood and newspaper reviews, here was a boy who just wanted his parents to come and watch.

The battle is on as two schools battle to get a five star reviewplaceholder image
The battle is on as two schools battle to get a five star review | Phoebe Roe-Parkin of Roie-Parkin Creative

It’s a funny assignment, reviewing a show about two schools trying to get five stars out of a theatre critic. Fortunately, this reviewer only had one production to comment on and it’s five stars for STOS!

Nativity! The Musical is at Sheffield’s Lyceum theatre until Saturday, November 21. Find out more and get involved with STOS at https://stos.org.uk/

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice