“This was not justice”: Sheffield ‘vigilantes’ commit “brutal” violence after getting caught up in social media frenzy

“This was not justice you were delivering”

A pair of Sheffield men have been sent to prison after attempting to deliver “vigilante justice” in a frenzy surrounding Facebook posts.

Sheldon Bowdler and Karl Pilgrim were brought into the docks of Sheffield Crown Court on Wednesday, November 11, to face charges of affray after they beat a man in broad daylight on Halifax Road, a dual carriageway running through Wadsley Bridge and Grenoside.

At a previous hearing on Friday, November 6, CCTV footage was shown to the court which prosecuting barrister Benjamin Bell said showed them “chase” the victim at around 11.30am on June 9, 2025, before he fell to the ground where they proceeded to “beat” and kick him.

Karl Pilgrim, 34 of Browning Drive (left) and 25-year-old Sheldon Bowdler of no fixed abode have been jailed after they chased down and beat a man on a busy road in Sheffield as an act of “vigilante justice”placeholder image
Karl Pilgrim, 34 of Browning Drive (left) and 25-year-old Sheldon Bowdler of no fixed abode have been jailed after they chased down and beat a man on a busy road in Sheffield as an act of “vigilante justice” | SYP

The pair also used a baseball bat to assault the victim while he was on the ground, with the court hearing that they repeatedly hit him in the head before leaving.

“The violence lasted around one minute in total,” Mr Bell added.

Bowdler and Pilgrim, aged 25 and 34 respectively, had become enraged after seeing social media posts on Facebook alleging that someone had been masturbating outside a nearby school when they embarked on their attack, the court heard.

It was explained in court that there was no evidence the victim had committed any offences and no charges had been brought against him.

Both defendants ultimately pleaded guilty to affray in relation to the attack.

Vannessa Saxton, who represents Pilgrim, of Browning Drive, said that her client was struggling with drug addiction at the time which he has since been seeking help for while on bail.

She explained that while using drugs it was his belief that the victim was “involved in behaviour that is very much frowned upon,” adding: “But his actions in dealing with that behaviour were perhaps not the best.”

Meanwhile, Bowdler’s representative Dermot Hughes told the court: “My client is not ordinarily violent - he has been caught up in something here.”

Mr Hughes explained how Bowdler, of no fixed abode, suffers with health difficulties and underwent spinal surgery since the offence.

Bowdler used crutches to walk while attending court.

Mr Hughes added that the case shows the “risk of seeing things on social media and getting caught up in the moment.”

“If you did believe an offence had occurred you should have done the responsible and reasonable thing and reported it to the police,” Judge Peter Hampton said when opening his sentencing remarks.

Sheffield Crown Courtplaceholder image
Sheffield Crown Court | Scott Merrylees

He went on to say: “Sadly you did not take that course.

“You two took it upon yourself to take matters into your own hands and you both embarked upon what can only be described, when viewing the CCTV, as an egregious, brutal act of violence.”

The judge described the pair as trying to dole out “vigilante justice” and that after considering the evidence and mitigating features concluding that the “only way an appropriate punishment can be achieved” was through immediate imprisonment.

“This was not justice you were delivering,” the judge continued.

“It was needless violence which had to be witnessed by member of the public going about their lives - men, women, children.”

Bowdler was sentenced to 18 months’ imprisonment.

Meanwhile Pilgrim was sentenced to 20 months’ imprisonment.

Someone shouted “I love you” from the public gallery as the pair were taken to cells.

Others said “you don’t know the full story” and “it’s a joke” as they left the courtroom.

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice