Familiar problems arose for Sheffield Wednesday as they were dumped out of the FA Cup at League Two Oldham Athletic.
It took 120 minutes to decide a bitty and physical clash in which the hosts took the lead twice. Davis Keillor-Dunn equalised in an improved Owls second half but in possession Wednesday looked ponderous on the ball, producing an xG of only 0.68 despite having been handed 71% possession.
The match marked a first defeat in an opening match for new Owls boss Dave Challinor, who looked a frustrated figure throughout and has problems to solve at S6. Here are our match ratings from a disappointing outing at Boundary Park.
9. Callum Slattery - 7
Broke through into the box first half to raise an optimistic penalty appeal. Showed some nice touches in moments and got about the pitch. Involved in a bizarre tet-a-tat with Micky Mellon that saw the Oldham boss red-carded. Generally up and about and grew into it. | ugc
10. Davis Keillor-Dunn - 7
Darted through to attempt to get to Valery's first half cross but was a step too late. Lost the ball too easily for the Oldham goal but got a mark back for a calm finish on the turn to level things up. Grew into it. | ugc
11. Jamal Lowe - 4
Struggled to get into the game in an outing of little opportunity for the leading man, but was too easily out-battled when they did spring up. Off midway through extra-time. | ugc
12. Connal Trueman - 5
In from the bench on 17 minutes after Maynard-Brewer's injury. Made a good save early on and was solid enough until he missed his punch for the winner. | The Star