Familiar problems arose for Sheffield Wednesday as they were dumped out of the FA Cup at League Two Oldham Athletic.
It took 120 minutes to decide a bitty and physical clash in which the hosts took the lead twice. Davis Keillor-Dunn equalised in an improved Owls second half but in possession Wednesday looked ponderous on the ball, producing an xG of only 0.68 despite having been handed 71% possession.
The match marked a first defeat in an opening match for new Owls boss Dave Challinor, who looked a frustrated figure throughout and has problems to solve at S6. Here are our match ratings from a disappointing outing at Boundary Park.
5. Di'Shon Bernard - 7
Back in the line-up and back to the edges of a back three. Sought to move the ball swiftly when he could but showed signs of rust. Defended strongly against the bombardment and did well to get through so much football as he did. Could have moved the ball faster. Hit wide late - and looked to have picked up an issue. | ugc
6. Jordi Liongola - 4
A surprise inclusion wide left - his height proved important in moments. Sliced open for Oldham's opener when he jumped in. Naturally rusty given it was his first outing since the first league game in August. Off after 70-odd. | ugc
7. Barry Bannan - 5
Sought to get on the ball and push things forward but failed to do it with regularity in a bitty game. Forced Hudson into his first save just before the hour with a strong technical shot from distance. Produced more as the game went on but will be disappointed. | ugc
8. Jaden Heskey - 5
Struggled to get into things consistently. Some nice touches in a congested area. One shot after the concession was probably the highlight from him in normal time - had a better extra-time. | ugc