After a drab 90 minutes with little in the way of real goalsciring opportunities for either side, the match was decided on spot kicks.
Youngster Louie Marsh and Benie Traore both missed before skipper John Egan skied the decisive penalty to cause a cup shock at Bramall Lane, with the League One side going through in front of their very vocal support.
Here's how we rated the Sheffield United players

9. Oliver Norwood - 7
The full repertoire of passes came out as Norwood's class stood out in the middle of the park. He sprayed balls all over the pitch and even tried an audacious effort on goal from his own half in a period where United weren't putting on too much pressure on goal. It was however well over Photo: DARREN STAPLES


11. Cameron Archer - 6
Played off the last man with McBurnie slightly deeper but definitely looked like a player who hadn't had a proper game in a while. A few moments of deft touches and really clever movement suggested there is a lot more to come from the new singing. Brought out a decent save from Jensen after good work from Marsh. Came off just after an hour which seemed like the plan from the outset Photo: Andrew Yates

12. Oli McBurnie - 6
Linked up well the odd time with Archer but they weren't quite on the same wavelength just yet. Still trying to find his way after coming back from injury, McBurnie was a nuisance as usual before coming off at the break for Traore Photo: SportImage


