After a drab 90 minutes with little in the way of real goalsciring opportunities for either side, the match was decided on spot kicks.
Youngster Louie Marsh and Benie Traore both missed before skipper John Egan skied the decisive penalty to cause a cup shock at Bramall Lane, with the League One side going through in front of their very vocal support.
Here's how we rated the Sheffield United players

13. Louie Marsh - 7
Missed his penalty but looks an incredible talent and the latest to come off the United academy conveyor belt. Looked so composed in the middle after coming on for the second half, played superb passes and showed a maturity that belied his years. A huge future ahead of him Photo: SportImage

14. Benie Traore - 6
Injected a little pace and trickery to the frontline when coming on after the break but faded a little as the game wore on. Missed a penalty in the shoot out Photo: Laurence Griffiths

15. Jili Buyabu - 6
Did well in his half hour showing, getting forward to good effect and looking comfortable in defence Photo: Simon Bellis

16. Femi Seriki - 6
Provided arguably the moment of the match with a great piece of skill and a cross that should have been turned in, in the final few minutes Photo: Andrew Yates


