John Lewis Sheffield: Historic England's worried warning over controversial plans for iconic listed landmark
Experts have slated plans to regenerate the listed former Cole Brothers building in Sheffield - warning it will ‘fundamentally alter the character’ and remove ‘key architectural elements’ of the Modernist ‘crown jewel’.
Both English Heritage and The Twentieth Century Society have attacked the plans for the building, which have been lodged with Sheffield Council by Urban Splash and AHMM.


While English Heritage have made clear their concerns over plans which they feel will change the Grade II listed landmark on Barker’s Pool, built in 1963, the Twentieth Century Society have also issued an objection to the planning application, which was lodged with Sheffield Council in September.
Both are concerned over the removal of brown ‘mosaic tiles’ from the outside of the building, and the replacement of the windows.
English Heritage backs plans for the inside of the building, home to John Lewis in the city until 2021.
But it says of planned work on the outside of the building: “A substantial redesign of its elevations is not compatible with conserving or enhancing a key part of its significance as a nationally important listed building.


“The current proposals are a missed opportunity to celebrate the architectural vision of this listed building, and the city of Sheffield deserves better.”
English Heritage says The Cole Brothers building sat as a jewel within the crown of Sheffield’s collection of very high-quality mid-20th century buildings, including Sheffield Cathedral, the Arts Tower, St Mark’s in Broomhill and Park Hill flats.
They added: “Given its city centre location, the Cole Brothers’ store was a key part of the vision for a prosperous Sheffield in the post-war period. YRMs’ (York Rosenberg and Mardall) architectural style very successfully corresponded with the ambitions of the John Lewis brand as well as the commercial optimism of Sheffield in the 1950s and 1960s.”
The Twentieth Century Society said in a letter to the planning department that it objected to the application on the basis that the proposal would cause significant harm to the heritage asset that was the Grade II-listed former Cole Brothers department store.
They said: “This level of harm to a listed building is unnecessary.”
Urban Splash says it is normal for there to be commentary on a listed building when it is changed, and it was a standard part of the consultation process. They say they are confident a mutually acceptable solution can be found.
Sheffield Council said in a statement: “The city council recognises the importance of securing a future for this listed building and we are working with the applicant’s team to consider the best response to address comments received from stakeholders, including Historic England.”
