Sheffield shops: Retail 'unlikely' to return to former Next plot on Fargate new owner says

The owner of a prime plot on Fargate has virtually ruled out another shop on the site.

The former Next site has been empty since the store was demolished three years ago.

In a prominent position on one of Sheffield’s most famous streets, many people have a keen interest in its future.

The former Next site has planning permission for a two-storey building.placeholder image
The former Next site has planning permission for a two-storey building. | Other

On The Star’s Facebook page, several readers said they want it to be a shop again, with some calling for a return of John Lewis.

But Sohail Yousaf, director of Sola Estates, which bought the site in 2024, said retail was “unlikely” because bricks-and-mortar shopping was in decline.

The firm is in talks with a regional restaurant operator and a regional bar operator, he added.

If they signed long term leases it could be a trigger a £2m construction project which already has planning permission.

Mr Yousaf said they were also talking to Sheffield City Council about adding more floors, of office space, to “make it viable” through additional rental income because commercial rents had declined.

He added: “We love the location but we have to make sure it is viable.

“We hope to agree a deal with operators in the next six months and could start building in 2026.”

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice