From Mick Lyons to Terry Curran, there are some legendary figures to have pulled on the two shirts.
So how about a full side, some subs and a legendary manager to pull the whole thing together?
We’re playing an attacking 3-5-2 formation, and it doesn’t look half bad. Let’s take a look at our who makes our ‘They Played for Both XI’?!

9. CM - Mark Pembridge
Often regarded as one of the truly underrated Sheffield Wednesday players, Mark Pembridge arrived from Derby County to play three seasons as a key player for the Owls. He left for Benfica in 1998 before enjoying a similarly successful spell on Merseyside. He played 54 times for Wales. Photo: Phil Cole

10. RM - Niclas Alexandersson
A real class act on his day, 109-cap Sweden legend Niclas Alexandersson signed for Wednesday from IFK Goteborg in 1997. He'd go on to win the club's player of the year award in their last Premier League season and subsequently moved to Everton for £2.5m. Photo: Clive Mason

11. CF - Terry Curran
A colourful character and an icon of Wednesday history, Curran was one of the most talented players of his generation. Promotion from the third division under his great friend Jack Charlton was followed by an ill-fated move to Bramall Lane, before three years at Everton that were littered with injuries and trophies in equal measure. Photo: Gary Stone

12. CF - Imre Varadi
A classy forward, Imre Varadi is a favourite among Wednesday supporters. Another who had two spells with the club, he also had two years with Everton after a short stint at Sheffield United. Photo: Getty Images

