From Mick Lyons to Terry Curran, there are some legendary figures to have pulled on the two shirts.
So how about a full side, some subs and a legendary manager to pull the whole thing together?
We’re playing an attacking 3-5-2 formation, and it doesn’t look half bad. Let’s take a look at our who makes our ‘They Played for Both XI’?!
We’re playing an attacking 3-5-2 formation, and it doesn’t look half bad. Let’s take a look at our who makes our ‘They Played for Both XI’?!
5. CB - Steve Watson
A stint at West Brom split the spells at Everton and Wednesday of defender Steve Watson, who saw out his career at S6, retiring in 2009. He had earlier played five years with the Toffees. Photo: Shaun Botterill
6. LM - Tony Kay
An England international of just one cap, Tony Kay would have had many more were it not for his involvement - and an incredibly harsh punishment - in a betting scandal. A quality performer, he played over 200 times for Wednesday before making the switch to Everton in 1962 and becoming the most expensive British footballer in history in doing so. Photo: Getty Images
7. MC - Ross Barkley
Barkley arrived for a short loan spell at Wednesday 2012, a move that seemed to kick start his career with four goals in 12 league matches. A boyhood Evertonian, he burst onto the scene as a teenager and has since earned a big-money move to Chelsea along with 33 England caps. Photo: Mark Robinson
8. CM - Gary Megson
Son of Wednesday legend Don, tough-tackling midfielder Gary Megson played well over 250 matches for the Owls over two spells in the 1980s. He'd played at Everton beforehand as a youngster. He later returned to Hillsborough as manager and is still revered at the club. Photo: JPIMedia