Sheffield United's defeat at Charlton Athletic tells bigger story than scoreline suggests as season narrative shifts
Sheffield United's defeat at Charlton Athletic tells bigger story than scoreline suggests as season narrative shifts
The history books show that, 10 years ago, Chris Wilder was on the way down to The Valley to potentially take over at Charlton Athletic when the call instead came from Sheffield United. What happened next was a remarkable chapter in United’s history.
Two promotions in three years; a Premier League tilt that saw them challenge for Europe before Covid-19 got in the way. Record transfer spends, attendances booming. Even last season, a remarkable promotion attempt before yet more Wembley pain.
In the context of Wilder’s achievements and memories as manager of his boyhood club, it can seem a little strange to add a 1-0 defeat at Charlton in mid-January. Especially with the home side newly back in the Championship and with United travelling south as the form team in the entire Championship.
But what the scoreline didn’t say, what will get lost in the annals of history as supporters in the future look back at the record books, is how the Blades bravely fought against the adversity of being down to NINE men for more than half of the game.
How they should have been out of sight in the first half, and how referee Oliver Langford missed a couple of big moments that could have swung the game in their favour, or at least evened it up. A blatant-looking early push on Patrick Bamford in the box, a late challenge from Harvey Knibbs on Sam McCallum before the madness truly began.
Instead both decisions went against United before two red cards in the space of a few late first-half minutes turned the game completely. First, Djibril Soumare miscontrolled a simple ball in midfield and smashed into Knibbs’ ankle.
Sheffield United's defeat at Charlton Athletic tells bigger story than scoreline suggests as season narrative shifts
It may not have been intentional, as Wilder insisted, but it was a shocker and left the Charlton man leaving the pitch on a stretcher. From there, United just needed to keep their heads, regroup and get through to half-time so they could go again.
What they didn’t need was their captain and one of their most experienced players to challenge for a header with Sonny Carey, the man who replaced Knibbs from the bench, and lead with his arms.
Wilder described it as a “poor decision” and it’s unarguable that Langford, who’d had a word with Tanganga to calm him down not long earlier, couldn’t wait to get his red card out of his pocket again, rather than give himself any thinking time whatsoever.
But whether it was a red card or not - there were no replays in the Valley press box and the only footage of the incident since has been grainy at best - Tanganga certainly looked fired up and his technique in trying to win the header gave Langford a decision to make.
United plan to appeal, Wilder said, and may well be successful in doing so, assuming there is clearer footage of the incident than has been seen so far. But that will do United no good in this game, or the nine men Tanganga left behind as he trudged from the field.
Those still on the pitch put in a performance as close to a typical Sheffield United one as you can imagine - full of grit and character and moments of quality, too, with a superb Michael Cooper save to deny Tyrese Campbell and a McCallum clearance off the line to keep the Blades in the game.
Their assembled supporters behind home man-of-the-match Thomas Kaminski’s goal responded to what they were seeing from their depleted side, and then some. A defiant chant insisting ‘it’s gonna be United all the way’ drifted into the south-east London air early in the second half and was still going well after the hour mark.
It was instead the home fans, whose side were a goal and two men to the good, who were nervy going into the final minutes while the Blades’ staff and players - minus two - soaked up deserved acclaim from their supporters at the end.
Afterwards, Wilder insisted that the game was right up there for him in terms of the proud moments he has had at this football club. His side, he felt, showcased everything that is good about this football club. Defiance in the face of adversity.
And how the supporters latched onto it. This season has been a tough one for them, with seven straight defeats at the start seeing them quickly transformed from promotion contenders to relegation candidates after a summer of torrid decisions from above that threaten to set United back years.
But they have seen enough in recent times, it seems, to believe that things are turning for the better, with the loudest chant of the afternoon coming in support of manager Wilder as he went over to thank them for their continuous backing.
There are still question marks about United and issues to solve. They should have been more clinical here, with chances for Bamford and Tom Cannon and Soumare going begging after the early penalty shout was waved away.
But this is a side unrecognisable from the one we saw, or rather endured, at the start of the campaign. Whatever happens from now on in, more spirited performances like this - preferably not with the handicap of two sendings-off - will surely help United climb the table.
The history books may record this as a one-nil defeat, Sonny Carey the hero for the home side just after half-time. But in the context of United’s season, which could yet have a big second half, it could mean a hell of a lot more.
