Moments of madness from Djibril Soumare and skipper Japhet Tanganga cost Sheffield United dear this afternoon as they lost at Charlton Athletic. The game looked like it would only have one winner in the first half with United having a host of golden chances.
But they were reduced to 10 men when Soumare saw red for a horror challenge on Harvey Knibbs and with United just needing to get through to half-time where they could regroup, Tanganga then followed him down the tunnel after an aerial challenge with Knibbs’ replacement Sonny Carey.
Charlton then made their two-man advantage pay by going ahead through Carey’s smart finish and from then on it was damage limitation for the remaining nine Blades players. Here’s how we rated United at the Valley...

1. Sheffield United player ratings v Charlton
Sheffield United player ratings v Charlton | UGC Photo: UGC

2. Michael Cooper 6
Was a virtual spectator in the first half as United dominated the game, at least until the two red cards changed the complexion of the game completely. There was a slightly dicey moment when he came out and got nowhere near the ball, and the United goalkeeper will have been mightily relieved to see the Charlton striker's touch take him towards the corner flag rather than the United goal. He made a superb save early in the second half to keep it at 1-0, after Campbell's effort was deflected off Seriki and arrowed towards his bottom corner | UGC Photo: UGC

3. Femi Seriki 6
Back in the side with Hoever on the bench after his debut on Sunday in the cup and played his part in a good offensive first-half display, including a delicious cross aimed at Bamford which Charlton just about managed to snuff out before it got to United's most in-form player. But his attacking ambition was limited and then snuffed out when United went down to 10 and then nine men and he instead was restricted to trying to keep the lively Campbell quiet | UGC Photo: UGC

4. Japhet Tanganga 0
His red card appeared slightly less clear cut than Soumare's but not by a great deal. With United already down to 10 men it was a time for cool heads but Tanganga did not have one of them, looking visibly wound up by a few decisions from ref Langford who couldn't get his red card out quick enough as Carey was polexed under the Blades skipper's aerial challenge | UGC Photo: UGC
