Here is how we rated the individual performances on a memorable afternoon at Bramall Lane.
1. Chris Basham 8
Doubled up at every opportunity with Baldock to stop Zaha and did the job brilliantly. Defended brilliantly against dangerous Benteke in the air and got forward when he could, too | Getty Images Photo: Nathan Stirk
2. Jack O'Connell 8
Suffered an early blow to the head in an aerial challenge with Benteke but recovered well with another commanding performance. Unfortunate not to score from a header, from Basham's looping cross | Getty Images Photo: Shaun Botterill
3. Enda Stevens 8
Never stopped running all game and one moment of skill, with a superb pirouette to take him away from his marker, was a particular highlight. Looked a threat all game alongside Baldock | Getty Images Photo: Nathan Stirk
4. Oliver Norwood 8
Superb again, screening the back four and using the ball effortlessly and intelligently. One sprayed pass to Baldock completely foxed van Aanholt. A real captain's display in the middle of the park | Getty Images Photo: Shaun Botterill