..and some made more of an impact across one or both sides of the city than others. How many of these had you sieved-out of your memory - wilfully or otherwise?!placeholder image
..and some made more of an impact across one or both sides of the city than others. How many of these had you sieved-out of your memory - wilfully or otherwise?!

17 players you may have forgotten played for both Sheffield United and Sheffield Wednesday - in pictures

We all know all about the Terry Curran switch, the ‘Geary, Quinn, Bromby’ triple steal and then there’s David McGoldrick. But what of the men you might not remember have played for both Sheffield clubs?

The two clubs have had a monumental crossover down the years and no fewer than 69 men have represented both the red and blue sides of the city, according to the English National Football Archive.

It’s hardly surprising perhaps, given the comparative size of the two clubs – see how we kept things neutral there?

Here’s a run-through of a few players that you might have forgotten once called both Hillsborough and Bramall Lane home.

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice