Sheffield United implosion might be only way Sheffield Wednesday get back on top for quite a while

Sheffield United hold the upper hand in the city now and it could be a while before that changes

Football in Sheffield is cyclical.... it's one thing that everyone can actually agree on.

Both Sheffield United and Sheffield Wednesday can, and have been, rubbish at the same time. Rarely are they both, really, any good together. But one generally has the upper hand.

This current period is no exception. United currently lord it, with Wednesday's defeat at Bramall Lane on Sunday finally confirming the inevitable... that they're likely to be at least one division below their rivals next season.

At some point it will change. Wednesday will be back and they'll be the ones gloating again; that's the way it goes around here. Even Chris Wilder admitted as much.

However, it's hard to really see when that will be.

As things stand, the takeover everyone of a blue and white persuasion craved while Dejphon Chaniri ran the club into the ground is yet to be rubber-stamped and the length of time it has taken for the James Bord-led group to get it by the EFL has given just cause for Owls fans to get a little nervous. Better safe than sorry, should be the mantra given what they've collectively been through.

No matter who gets their name above the door at Hillsborough, the amount of work they have facing them is astounding.

Off the pitch, the club is a relic and huge investment is needed in a tired old ground and frankly embarrassing training facilities for a club of this supposed stature.

placeholder image
PA

That could lead to the new owners having a big decision to make because on the pitch, this current Wednesday squad isn't good enough to get promoted from League One. And it's not just a handful of players short of mounting that challenge either.

Yes, there are a number of very talented youngsters coming through who have been given an opportunity well before they should have and it's an experience that should hold them in good stead - if it hasn't put them off football for good - but there's nowhere near enough quality collectively to cope with a long ardous season in League One.

On Sunday, with the home side cruising to a 2-0 lead at Bramall Lane, it took United's on-loan midfielder Kalvin Phillips to see red for a stupidly rash tackle on Svante Ingelsson for Wednesday to even make the match competitive. To their credit, they seized the opportunity and scored through Charlie McNeill but despite some nerves amongst supporters, the Blades never really looked like they weren't going to win. The annoyance from their point of view was that Phillips' sending off sucked the momentum out of their game and what looked like it could have been an all-timer of a scoreline became one that appeared as though they just about made it over the line.

In truth, though, Wednesday just didn't have it in them, even against ten men.

There comes the dilemma facing any prospective new owner. Do they throw together what in reality needs to be almost an entirely new squad and with it a fairly sizable investment in immediate large-scale recruitment? Or do they take a more pragmatic approach and rebuild slowly?

The latter seems like the most sensible approach but the question is, does everyone have the patience for it?

All the while, over in the other side of town, they should be looking up.and they'll rightfully revel in their rivals' misery because that's what being in a two-club city such as this is about.

Chance for Sheffield United to really put distance between themselves and Sheffield Wednesday but will they take it?

United now have the opportunity to put some real distance between themselves and Wednesday, such is the rebuild that needs to take place in S6. That could still happen this season, with a play-off place still not out of the question. They would have been in a much better position had their owners not rolled up a plan and kicked it down Shoreham Street by sacking Wilder and replacing him with Ruben Selles.

That they went back on the decision at least showed some humility but it was an early example of how a wrong call can cause huge damage.

Currently, it's going to take an equally explosive decision, or a series of destructive little ones from the powers-that-be at Bramall Lane to turn Sheffield's football cycle back towards Wednesday, because the blue side don't have it in them to do it by themselves for quite a while yet.

The way things are in this city, you wouldn't even rule that out either.

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice