3pm blackout proposal sparks concern among Sheffield non-league clubs

Sheffield clubs have their say on calls to scrap the Saturday afternoon TV blackout, amid concerns over the impact on football's lower leagues.

Non-league clubs in Sheffield have reacted to the debate around the potential scrapping of the 3pm kick-off blackout.

HULL, ENGLAND - OCTOBER 11: A mobile television cameraman in actio during the Premier League 2026/27 match between Hull City and Everton at MKM Stadium on October 11, 2026 in Hull, England. (Photo by Stu Forster/Getty Images)placeholder image
HULL, ENGLAND - OCTOBER 11: A mobile television cameraman in actio during the Premier League 2026/27 match between Hull City and Everton at MKM Stadium on October 11, 2026 in Hull, England. (Photo by Stu Forster/Getty Images) | Getty Images

Rupert Lowe, MP for Great Yarmouth in Norfolk, and former chairman of Southampton addressed the House of Commons on Thursday, November 12, calling for the government to work with the FA and abolish the policy that was designed to protect football clubs lower down the pyramid, first brought in in the 1960s.

The current law, which is part of UEFA’s Article 48, bans any live broadcast of Premier League, EFL, FA Cup and EFL Cup matches that kick off between the hours of 2:45 pm and 5:15 pm on a Saturday.

Under the current broadcasting deal, 70 per cent of Premier League fixtures (267 of 380) are shown live on Sky Sports and TNT Sports, leaving the remaining 30 per cent unavailable to watch live in the UK.

The next major domestic broadcasting rights cycle begins in 2029-30 and Premier League chief executive Richard Masters has indicated that discussions with the EFL will take place. The main crux of the argument from fans is that supporters from all over the world can watch these three o’clock kick-offs, yet people in this country can’t. That fact is hard to argue against, but it’s just not that simple.

Prime Minister Andy Burnham said he would ‘urge caution' and highlighted the impact it could have on non-league sides.

“I would urge a bit of caution on it (the blackout), because it does protect the income of lower-league clubs,” he said. “If you have effectively wall-to-wall Premier League football at any time, it takes away perhaps the incentive to go and watch the football league or non-league.

“So I think it has to be considered carefully. I’m not going to take the pure consumer view here. I’ll take the health-of-football approach to this particular issue,” he continued. “I would first of all want to protect the football pyramid before I agree.”

“It’s about protecting the experience with the paying supporter.”

Prime Minister Andy Burnham has urged caution over the 3pm blackout (Leon Neal/PA)placeholder image
Prime Minister Andy Burnham has urged caution over the 3pm blackout (Leon Neal/PA) | PA

The PM highlighted it wasn’t a ‘decision for now’ and that he’d address it in ‘about 18 months' time’.

Stocksbridge Park Steels currently play in the eighth tier of the pyramid, competing in the Northern Premier League Division One East.

A club spokesperson warned that scrapping the blackout would put further financial pressure on a side that already struggles to make any profit.

“It affects every non-league football club,” they said. “We've had issues already because of the amount of football that's on the television. We find now that some people just don't go out because it's cold, when you can sit and watch a game on TNT or switch to Sky and Sky is showing about 20 of them, so it does affect the crowds.

“Any finances that we lose are a massive problem because, as a community club, we've got no owners. It's run by trustees. We don't have a rich chairman that just chucks money at it. We've got to be sustainable, support ourselves.”

Stocksbridge averages around 240 supporters through the turnstiles at a home match, and the club spokesperson admitted it’s their main source of income.

“We have the Football Association telling us what the ground should look like. They've got this magic wand that says every ground should look like Wembley.”

The club had to fork out several thousand pounds for stadium improvements when they got promoted in the 2024/25 season, which was mainly paid for by fundraising events.

“Sheffield City Council has not really helped us much at all with anything, and we haven't seen our local MP since she was elected. So, we don't get any support from them, but political parties should stay out of football.

“Politics and football, well, any sport, it doesn't mix. Everyone's got their own opinion, and sometimes it can cause aggravation at a ground, people mentioning certain things, and you think, well, let's not go there, let's just watch football.”

“I'm all for football at three o'clock because I think that's where it should be. You get the games now in the Premier Division, you don't know whether they're playing Fridays, Thursdays, Tuesdays. There's no consistency, and I think this is where it's spoiling it for the people that do actually go. Those numbers are not growing.”

David Elliot, chairman at Penistone Church FC, who compete in the ninth tier, takes a similar stance to Stockbridge, but argued nobody can truly predict what the affect would be.

“At the moment we would need to see more details before we thought it was or was not a good idea,” he said.

“It could be that we get more people in the clubhouse who are watching a game and watching Penistone as well. We don't know; we have to look for positives in it.

“I think it's going to be something that a lot of people, especially when you get onto the bigger clubs, they're going to be more against it. That said, most Premier League clubs don't play at three o'clock on a Saturday, so they're probably the least affected. So further down the football chain that you go, it will affect [them] more. But for us, we would watch it with interest.”

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice