Cole Brothers: Twentieth Century Society responds after Sheffield MP criticises stance on revamp

A conservation group has insisted it does not want to block redevelopment of the Cole Brothers building in Sheffield.

The Twentieth Century Society says there is great potential for the changes needed to bring the former John Lewis store back to life.

But its architectural significance and its importance for the character of Sheffield city centre must be respected.

Artist's impression of revamped Cole Brothers building.placeholder image
Artist's impression of revamped Cole Brothers building. | Urban Splash

The organisation responded after Sheffield MP Clive Betts criticised Historic England and the Twentieth Century Society for objecting to proposals “with no plans of their own.”

Developer Urban Splash has submitted a planning application to change the Barker’s Pool building into offices ‘underpinned by active ground floor and cultural uses’, claiming it could support up to 1,000 jobs.

It was Grade II-listed in 2022 following a 20-year campaign by the Twentieth Century Society.

The Cole Brothers building today.placeholder image
The Cole Brothers building today. | Finn Smith

The society says it is important in terms of its architectural significance but also for its place within the memories of those living and working in Sheffield.

A spokesperson said: “While we have objected to the scheme, this is part of a normal and constructive planning process.

“The feedback of organisations like ours and Historic England is key to protecting and conserving the built heritage which makes up our cities.

“Our aim is not to block the scheme or to stop development from happening.

“The best outcome for all is for this important building to be brought back into use. We welcome proposals to safeguard the former Cole Brothers building into the future but these changes cannot forget that this building is listed and that holds importance too.

“At Cole Brothers, like at the Grade II* listed Park Hill, there is great potential for the transformative change needed to ensure the building can be reimagined with a new life. But let’s do this while recognising and respecting its architectural significance and the importance it plays for the character of Sheffield city centre.”

The former store was designed by York Rosenberg & Mardall and completed in 1963.

It became John Lewis in 2002. It closed with the loss of 299 jobs in 2021.

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice