Whistleblower claims "meaningful change" has not been implemented in year since Sheffield school murder
A whistleblower at the trust responsible for the Sheffield school where 15-year-old Harvey Willgoose was murdered by a fellow pupil has spoken out, claiming “meaningful change has not been implemented” in the year since the teen’s tragic death.
Mohammed Umar Khan, also 15 at the time, fatally stabbed classmate Harvey in full view of staff and students at All Saints Catholic High School a few minutes into the lunchtime break on Monday, February 3, 2025.
A report detailing the findings of an external review into the killing of Harvey at the school, part of St Clare Catholic Multi Academy Trust, found “several missed opportunities” to act on serious warning signs relating to Khan, including more than 130 incidents logged at his previous school, some of which involved violence, gangs and weapons.


In response to the report, which was commissioned by St Clare Catholic Multi Academy Trust (SCCMAT) but has not been released to the public, Harvey’s dad, Mark, described it as “damning - which is why we want it published in full.”
Some of the contents of the report were released by the family and their lawyers to mark the first anniversary of Harvey’s death.
SCCMAT Chief Executive Officer Steve Davies acknowledged the report identified areas for improvement, but said they have “already implemented a number of robust measures over the last year.”
However, a SCCMAT employee has now spoken to The Star to highlight a number of concerns, in the hope their anonymous whistleblowing could help to keep staff and students safe and prevent another tragedy from taking place.
Each of the issues raised has been put to SCCMAT, who, in turn, has been given the opportunity to comment.
Amongst the concerns raised by the employee, whose identity and employment has been verified by The Star, is that “meaningful change has not been implemented,” since the fatal stabbing; and they fear there is therefore a possibility that similar incidents could take place in the future.
The whistleblower says some staff are concerned that weapons are still being brought into All Saints.
It comes after Khan’s Sheffield Crown Court trial heard how the teen brought a knife into school and posed for a picture with it in a separate incident prior to Harvey’s death. His mum also found an axe in his bag on another occasion and notified the school.
Harvey’s family said the report from the external investigator Learn Sheffield revealed All Saints failed to act after pupils reported that Khan had brought a BB gun and knife with him during a school trip.
SCCMAT did not respond in the comment provided to these specific concerns, but said the changes implemented over the past year have been highlighted in documents sent to The Star around the report recommendations, detailing the measures already in place, along with changes made specifically in response to some of the recommendations.
The changes highlighted by SCCMAT are in a number of areas. This includes:
- Their process for transfers, which, the trust says, has seen them widen “the team of people who review information and inform sign-off”
- Their system for recording knife-related events, involving training on the most accurate and effective way of recording incidents and a weekly audit of all logs, initiated by the Deputy and Assistant Head.
- Staff training around searching, screening and confiscation, including updated protocols for searching and recording following advice from the Sheffield Children Safeguarding Partnership and a new follow-up system involving a set six-week safety plan in the event of a weapon search
- Their process for responding to knife-related incidents, including a new system where there are regular meetings of senior leaders, safeguarding and pastoral staff solely focused on specific safeguarding matters in relation to violence
- Referrals to social care and “how follow-ups are made by school staff for particularly complex cases to ensure that the pupil is receiving adequate specialised support from the social care services”
- Introduction of additional security measures, including handheld metal detectors - also known as “wands” - to be used by trained staff members; refresher staff training sessions on safe student restraint and a bleed kit has being installed at the school courtesy of a “generous” charity donation
The whistleblower says they are concerned that lockdown procedures at the school are “unclear,” resulting in staff being unsure of who should do what in the event of an incident similar to the one in which Harvey was killed.
In response to the lockdown concerns, The Star asked SCCMAT to confirm whether a full lockdown drill had been carried out at the school in the year since Harvey’s death.
A SCCMAT spokesperson said: “We have a robust and effective lockdown system in place.
“Periodic lockdown drills are held and reviews are undertaken after every single drill – a part of this review includes the opportunity for feedback from all staff on improvements and other areas.
“We have carried out a number of lockdown procedures and a full lockdown drill since Harvey's death which was done with care and consideration for pupils’ wellbeing.”
The SCCMAT statement in full reads:
“Since the terrible tragedy of Harvey’s death staff have displayed enormous professionalism and care in their duties and there is a great sense of support from the staff body as we work together towards making the school as safe as possible.
“We have a robust and effective lockdown system in place.
“Periodic lockdown drills are held and reviews are undertaken after every single drill – a part of this review includes the opportunity for feedback from all staff on improvements and other areas.
“We have carried out a number of lockdown procedures and a full lockdown drill since Harvey's death which was done with care and consideration for pupil's wellbeing.
“There are a number of supports in place for the mental health of students and staff.
“For individual students and staff we have specialist counselling services in place that have been available since the incident and remain in place and are highly valued by the community.
“We also have undertaken significant work across the community on supporting wellbeing through regular workshops, seminars and monthly drop-ins with various external agencies such as South Yorkshire Police, The Sheffield Parenting Hub and the children's psychological support charity Unravel.
“These actions, together with the individual levels of support available underline the strong support that is available for our students and staff and the robust measures we have taken to improve student safety.
“The claims of your one anonymous source are in no way representative of the experience of our community, which we remain committed to supporting as we continue to implement the report's recommendations.”
“Every school, every parent should get sight of report”
Members of Harvey’s family, including mum Caroline Willgoose, father Mark Willgoose and grandmother Maria Turner, attended a press conference on Monday (February 2, 2026), and called for the report from the external schools investigator to be published in full.
“I urge the school to publish that report so every school, every parent should get sight of it and make sure that changes are made and that schools are made safer in the future,” said Maria.
Whilst SCCMAT has not yet published the report, they have provided The Star with the 10 recommendations arising from it.
They include recommendations for change around processes, information-sharing, training, safeguarding and recording of, and responses to, knife-related incidents.
The investigator has also called on SCCMAT to commission an external safeguarding audit of the school's safeguarding leadership, systems and culture.
Khan, aged 16, formerly of City Road, Sheffield, was convicted of Harvey’s murder at the conclusion of a Sheffield Crown Court trial in August 2025, after denying the offence.
In October 2025, he was sentenced to 16 years at His Majesty’s Pleasure.
During the same hearing, an automatic reporting restriction protecting Khan’s identity was lifted - allowing him to be named - following applications from The Star, and others.