Breaking

Harvey Willgoose murder: School issues statement as investigator completes report into fatal incident

A Sheffield school at the centre of a pupil-on-pupil murder says it has implemented a number of robust measures in the year since the fatal stabbing, as an external investigator completes its report.

Mohammed Umar Khan, aged 15 at the time, stabbed classmate Harvey Willgoose, also 15, during an incident in the courtyard of their school, All Saints Catholic High School, a few minutes into the lunch break on February 3, 2025.

Harvey could not be saved, and died a short time later.

Khan, formerly of City Road, Sheffield, was convicted of Harvey’s murder at the conclusion of a Sheffield Crown Court, and sentenced to 16 years at His Majesty’s Pleasure.

Mohammed Umar Khan stabbed classmate Harvey Willgoose, also 15, during an incident in the courtyard of their school, All Saints Catholic High School, a few minutes into the lunch break on February 3, 2025placeholder image
Mohammed Umar Khan stabbed classmate Harvey Willgoose, also 15, during an incident in the courtyard of their school, All Saints Catholic High School, a few minutes into the lunch break on February 3, 2025 | Left: Caroline Willgoose; right: PA Media

Now, almost exactly a year since Harvey’s tragic death, a spokesperson for St Clare Catholic Multi Academy Trust - the body responsible for All Saints - has confirmed that it has received recommendations arising from a report compiled by external investigator, Learn Sheffield, following the fatal incident.

“Report has identified areas for improvement...and we have already implemented a number of robust measures”

St Clare Catholic Multi Academy Trust (SCCMAT) has provided The Star with a list of 10 recommendations arising from the report, but not the report itself or a summary of its findings. It is understood that the Willgoose family has received a copy of the report, however.

SCCMAT has not responded to questions over whether the report’s findings have resulted in any resignations or dismissals.

It has provided a statement from the Chief Executive Officer of SCCMAT, Steve Davies, however, in which he said it is clear the report has identified areas for improvement, including in relation to “our processes, information-sharing, and training.”

He continued: “We are engaging with an external safeguarding expert to advise on how we can implement the recommendations across the school and, where appropriate, the Trust as a whole.

“We have already implemented a number of robust measures over the last year and will continue to take action in line with the report’s recommendations and external advice from the statutory safeguarding agencies.”

Mark and Harvey Willgooseplaceholder image
Mark and Harvey Willgoose | Submit

Knife-related events, and how the school responds to, and records, such incidents

Ensuring “safeguarding and behaviour systems are set-up to better record knife-related events, so that relevant staff are sighted on the events,” is amongst the recommendations set out by the investigator, who was commissioned by SCCMAT.

During the course of Khan’s trial, the court heard how he was able to bring a knife into school grounds on one occasion prior to Harvey’s death. A picture taken from Khan’s phone, showing him posing with the knife in a wooded area within the school, was shown to jurors.

In addition, the school was contacted by Khan’s mother in late December 2024 - less than two months before Harvey’s death - after she found an axe in his bag. The school contacted police, who subsequently sent an officer to speak with Khan about “the dangers of carrying weapons”; but it has not disclosed whether any disciplinary action was taken against Khan in the wake of the discovery.

Khan told jurors that he bought the axe from a fellow pupil, whilst on school premises, after initially asking to buy a knife from them.

The investigator has suggested that better recording of “knife-related events” should include: all instances of reports of weapons being categorised as such, not as general behaviour incidents; routine and regular monitoring of weapons incidents by the relevant senior leader; clarity about who has responsibility for taking action and sharing information and training for staff concerning what should be recorded, where and when.

In response to this specific recommendation, a SCCMAT spokesperson said the school has implemented a number of changes, after reviewing the system in place. The changes, say SCCMAT, include training for the school’s inclusion team “on the most accurate and effective way to record incidents to ensure maximum visibility across relevant senior leaders and that risks can be flagged early and robustly.”

The spokesperson added that refresher training is to be “embedded every half-term” in order to maintain high standards and ensure continuity.

Another recommendation set out calls on the school to develop a policy for how the school should respond to an instance, or report, of a knife-related event, including for off-site reports.

It suggests the policy should include: a requirement to always investigate; to always isolate the pupil during the investigation, other than by exception; to always involve the (Designated Safeguarding Lead) in assessing the appropriate action to take and an assumption that whenever there is a credible report of a pupil possessing a weapon, leaders should implement a risk assessment and safety plan, unless there is a compelling reason not to do so.

The investigator has also recommended that when a weapon is found, including when it is off-site, a risk assessment and safety plan must be put in place, and shared with all staff.

A SCCMAT spokesperson said the Trust has implemented some “key measures” around how staff should respond to knife-related incidents, which include a “clear, six-week plan” being put in place for students alleged to be involved in knife-related incidents.

They added: “We have instituted a new system where there are regular meetings of senior leaders, safeguarding and pastoral staff solely focused on specific safeguarding matters in relation to violence. Searches are a standing item in these meetings and all in the team must be notified if a search has happened and updated as to what the follow-up process is.”

Weapon searches, safeguarding and leadership

The investigator has also recommended that staff are provided with training in the Government’s guidance on weapon searching, screening and confiscation.

This, says the investigator, should include training on: how to carry out a search, including what can be searched; thorough recording of the search; the necessary notifications following a search and how to follow-up a search, even when no prohibited items are found.

The SCCMAT spokesperson told The Star that a number of additional security measures have been brought in since Harvey’s death, including the introduction of handheld metal detectors (also known as ‘wands’) to be used by trained staff members should they suspect a student of carrying any banned objects on their person.

A number of the other recommendations relate to leadership at the school, including a review of the structures in place, and safeguarding.

SCCMAT is being called upon to commission an external safeguarding audit of the school's safeguarding leadership, systems and culture.

In addition, the investigator has also suggested clarification is needed around who holds the responsibility for reviewing pupil safeguarding and behaviour records; who holds responsibility for taking action.

“Safeguarding leaders should ensure that they follow-up on all referrals to children's social care to satisfy themselves that appropriate is action is being taken,” the investigator has said.

“Remembering Harvey’s fun-loving personality”

Mr Davies continued: “The issues this report raises will also resonate more widely across the education sector.

“We hope the findings can contribute to a wider discussion about the support, guidance and frameworks schools need nationally to respond consistently and safely to the evolving safeguarding challenges affecting young people.

Above all else, as we approach Harvey’s anniversary we remember his fun-loving and kind personality and extend our deepest condolences to his family and loved ones.”

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice