Sheffield potholes: Ex GP's battle against the potholes which led him to pack up cycling
Retired GP Geoff Shrecker is fed up with Sheffield’s potholed roads.
When he was working as a family doctor in the city, he encouraged his patients to take exercise. But, once a keen cyclist, he decided to pack in riding his bike largely because he felt it was unsafe on the city’s potholed roads.
He also feels that Sheffield’s 2012 deal to re-lay its roads has not been what he expected, as the roads he feels residents thought would last for decades were showing holes within just a few years, he claims.


Now he has signed up for a scheme to report potholes in the city’s streets instantly, via his dashcam.
Geoff, from Broomhill, said: “Back in the days when I was a GP I used to do quite a lot of cycling. In those days Cycling UK had an app that you could put pot holes in when you saw them, and that would report it to the council.
“Pot holes can be really nasty for cyclists, and can do a lot of damage to riders if they cause a fall. I retired as a GP nine years ago and pretty much gave up cycling because I now feel it’s dangerous around Sheffield
“But what really cheeses me off is that we had all this work done around 10 years ago, which saw roads closed while they were resurfaced, and we expected them to be perfect for 30 years. Within weeks they were deteriorating. I don’t feel it has done what we were told it would.”


He has signed up to a project run by dashcam manufacturer Nextbase, who offered him a change to join their ‘Road Safety Club ‘ showing multiple potholes on everyday local routes. He has started sharing footages of pot holes through the camera, which the company says it then uses to notify local authorities.
Among the recent ones was a section of road on Woodhead Road, Sharrow, near its junction with Alderson Road, which he said appeared to have lost most of its top surface.
Geoff used to encourage his patients to exercise when he was a GP at Gleadless Medical Centre. He said the ones that got plenty of exercise were the ones that he saw less often, and feels the state of the roads is important for people to be able to do what the local authority calls ‘active travel.’
Sheffield Council signed a contract with the engineering firm Amey in 2012, which was described as the biggest PFI highways maintenance contract in the UK, It saw all the city’s roads resurfaced.


Geoff joined the ‘Road Safety Club’ after seeing it in the Nextbase app, to make it easier to report issues like potholes and dangerous driving.
Bryn Brooker, Head of Road Safety at Nextbase, said of their scheme: “The billions of miles reported by the Road Safety Club demonstrate the scale of infrastructure challenges the UK faces, while the visual evidence we're collecting from our dash cams can be crucial for the transparency being called for by unhappy councils.
“While we welcome the recent attention potholes have received, this shouldn't be treated as a once-a-year exercise. It needs to fit into a wider, ongoing conversation about the state of our roads."
Sheffield Council has defended the condition of its roads, and says the city has undergone one of the largest highway improvement programmes in the country since the Streets Ahead PFI contract began in 2012, a time at which the city had developed a reputation as ‘pothole city’.
As with any highway network, routine maintenance will always be required, and some heavily trafficked routes will need additional work over time due to higher levels of wear and tear.
The Streets Ahead programme is a 25‑year contract and the city is now halfway through, with around 83 per cent of the city’s road network having been fully resurfaced.
The council said in a statement: “As with any highway network, routine maintenance will always be required, and some heavily trafficked routes will need additional work over time due to higher levels of wear and tear. This is normal for a city of Sheffield’s size and geography.
“Despite this, Sheffield’s road condition compares favourably with other local authorities in Yorkshire and nationally. The latest Department for Transport Road Condition Statistics, published in December 2024, show that only one per cent of Sheffield’s A‑roads were assessed as requiring maintenance.
“In the most recent National Highways & Transport (NHT) Public Satisfaction Survey, Sheffield ranked as having the sixth best roads in the country.”
Stay up to date on all of the latest news stories in Sheffield and South Yorkshire with The Star’s daily newsletter, sign up today.
They said due to the long‑term investment secured through the PFI, Sheffield does not receive additional government highways funding, but its network continues to benefit from consistent, planned maintenance.
The statement added: “We remain committed to ensuring Sheffield’s roads are safe and well‑maintained, and we encourage residents to continue reporting any defects they encounter so that they can be addressed promptly.
“We would advise people to report any defects on the highway via the council's website (https://www.sheffield.gov.uk/roads-pavements/report-road-problems), emailing [email protected], contacting Customer Services on 0114 273 4567, or using the FixMyStreet app (https://www.fixmystreet.com). This ensures that reports are received, formally logged and passed on to the appropriate team or staff member. “
