Sheffield parking: Residents explain what difference free parking would make in Sheffield city centre

Residents have explained what they think would happen if free parking was brought into Sheffield city centre.

Rotherham Council introduced some free parking in their town centre car parks this summer, but Sheffield residents still pay, with some concerned about the number of car parks too.

Would free parking make you more likely to visit Sheffield city centre? Picture shows Fitzwilliam Street car park next to Devonshire Green. Photo: Googleplaceholder image
Would free parking make you more likely to visit Sheffield city centre? Picture shows Fitzwilliam Street car park next to Devonshire Green. Photo: Google | Google

The Star asked readers if they thought free parking would tempt you into the city centre more?

And while some were clear that it would, others thought other things were more important in getting them into town.

Here were some of the views saying that free parking would tempt then into the city more.

Christine Mary Mccloskey said: “It would help but would be better if the buses were allowed down the Moor again or just down Pinstone Street. Would also be a big help if there were some decent shops and less coffee places Atkinsons is the only department store left the others are just temporary now the council need to remember not everyone wants to go to Meadowhall they should cater for the residents not just students who come and go.”

Jenny Barker said: “Yes, definitely. Used to be free on Sundays which was really handy as it was never busy, so no need to use charging to reduce demand in spaces. That said at £10 a visit it's the ULEZ that's the main barrier to city centre shopping for me.”

Matt Green said: “100 per cent - I'd use it over going on Amazon probably.”

Jackie Parker said: “That and a few half decent shops might!!”

Some feel cheaper buses going to the areas where people want them to go is more important. Photo: Dean Atkinsplaceholder image
Some feel cheaper buses going to the areas where people want them to go is more important. Photo: Dean Atkins

Caroline Hague said: “Yes. Thought I’d go to the markets today to support local butchers etc. Parked in The Moor car park next door. Was pleased to hear I could validate my token for a discount. Turned out it was 10p. Hardly encouraging.”

Peter David Walker said: “Yep. Ask around, and a lot of people prefer the choice of walking around town/city centres, as opposed to shopping malls like Meadowhall. Obviously, some people prefer the Meadowhall type option. However, with the city centre option, you often get more choices for certain products and, therefore, can obtain better value for money, etc. However, drop on the car parking charges and Meadowhall will win every time, simply because it's free. People often don't factor in the cost of commuting to Meadowhall, because the fuel is already paid for, in the vehicle. But I honestly believe if Councils dropped the car parking charges completely, it can only promote more punters into town/city centres? However, the one downside to this is, possibly gridlocked roads?”

Clothes The Loop said: “I think this would be amazing. As a small business owner in the centre, I have this conversation all the time - the paid parking pushes people to Meadowhall, so we miss out on the trade! Why can’t we trial it throughout December on a Sunday and get some traction to the Xmas markets too?”

Susan Smith added: “Yes definitely we used to come regularly on a Sunday to do shopping and then go for a meal but parking charges stopped that.”

However others felt parking was not a problem.

Peter Matanle said: “I regularly go to the city centre by car. It's easy to find a space and not so expensive, if you know where the cheaper places are.”

And Dan Clarke added: “Loads of cheap parking in Sheffield. NCP Solly Street is £3.50 all day on Saturday. Cheaper than a return bus ticket.”

Others felt it was more important to have something giving them a reason to go into the city centre.

Clare Elderkin said: “No. There also needs to be something to go there FOR. I used to love Debenhams and John Lewis. Those particular stores aren't coming back, but surely there could be something of a similar quality, selection and price point?”

And some feel that better and cheaper buses going through the city centre were more important.

Geoff Schrecker saidL “No, but free buses or cheaper bus fares would. It’s cheaper for my wife and I to drive and park than two return trips with two buses each way.”

Judy Mitchell said: “Public transport taking us right into the city centre would be great. It was fine when the buses went along Leopold Street, Pinstone Street and down towards the Moor, but now there's a lengthy walk to any shops, not to mention dodging speeding cyclists.”

James Kemp added: “No because they’d do you for going down a bus lane without warning.

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice