Sheffield Council adult social care overspending “a challenge beyond challenges”

A huge overspend in providing adult social care in Sheffield has been scrutinised by councillors and external auditors.

Rising demand for adult social care is one of the major funding issues facing Sheffield City Council. The current overall overspending forecast for 2025/6 stands at £23.6 million but the council says it is on track to bring this below £20 million by the end of the financial year.

Coun Terry Fox, former leader of Sheffield City Council and a member of the audit and standards committee. Picture: Sheffield Council webcastplaceholder image
Coun Terry Fox, former leader of Sheffield City Council and a member of the audit and standards committee. Picture: Sheffield Council webcast

Action to manage the situation has reduced forecast overspending by £4.6 million overall.

Adult social care has improved its position by £5 million since April. The council says this is because of “smarter planning, better use of data, and targeted savings”. Other areas with the greatest overspending on budgets are children’s social care, temporary accommodation for homeless people and the cost of home to school transport for children with special educational needs and disabilities (SEND).

Sheffield City Council director of finance and commercial services Philip Gregory and Jane Wilby, assistant director of finance and accounting. Picture: Sheffield Council webcastplaceholder image
Sheffield City Council director of finance and commercial services Philip Gregory and Jane Wilby, assistant director of finance and accounting. Picture: Sheffield Council webcast

Action is taking place to change the way all those services are delivered to cut costs.

Challenge

External auditor KPMG last week (November 20) presented its initial findings on the council finances for 2024/5 to the audit and standards committee.

The auditor’s draft annual report said: “Adult social care is facing increased demand in numbers of people they need to support and an increase in the cost per person. 2025-26 budget projected to be £34.6m overspent.”

Coun Terry Fox said: “It’ll come as no surprise that social care has been a challenge beyond challenges and I don’t see any changes to that going forward, due to the fact that there are so many unquantifiables.”

He asked if there was anything more the council should put in place: “Is there something we are missing or something else we should be considering, certainly when coming into making those decisions as policy-makers?”

Tim Cutler of KPMG replied that the adult social care leadership team has done a lot of work over the past 12 months to understand what improvements could be made. He added that high spending on adult social care is a national issue for councils.

“Will you ever be in a situation where there is no pressure? No, that is unrealistic,” he added.

Proportionate

“What you have done is proportionate. You have looked at some of the processes you can improve and sought external support which is better placed to look at the best practices you can bring into the authority.

“As an external auditor, I think the improvement plan you’ve pulled together is pretty much the best it can be.”

He said the improvement plan would need close monitoring. “Where actions don’t have the desired effect, challenge on what the approach needs to be.”

In response to a question from Coun Matthew Dwyer, Mr Cutler said the same issue is affecting a lot of local authorities.

Director of finance and commercial services Philip Gregory told the committee that the budget-setting approach has changed over the past two years.

The aim is to give services the budget they need so they are not overspent early in the financial year and so they can withstand pressures caused by increased demand.

Assistant director of finance and accounting Jane Wilby said that a lot of work has gone into more accurate forecasting of demand and when it is likely to spike. Mr Gregory said some spikes in demand have been unexpected.

Committee chair Coun Tim Huggan said he wants to see a council budget that is more accurate from day one.

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice