Campaigners oppose government move to return council to unpopular decision-making system – “Sheffield can’t go back”

Two Sheffield campaigns have condemned government plans that would see a cabinet-style model that was rejected four years ago returning to the city council.

The group It’s Our City! successfully campaigned for and won a citywide referendum in May 2021 that led to the scrapping of the council’s cabinet model of leadership in favour of a policy committee system that aims to be more inclusive of all 84 councillors in decision-making.

It's Our City campaigners who won a Sheffield referendum to move the city council away from a cabinet model of decision-making are opposing government moves to bring it backplaceholder image
It's Our City campaigners who won a Sheffield referendum to move the city council away from a cabinet model of decision-making are opposing government moves to bring it back

Jim McMahon, minister for local government and English devolution, last week announced plans for legislation that would require all councils to adopt a leader and cabinet model of decision-making. That would reverse the referendum result.

The council issued a statement saying it would seek urgent talks with the government. The council’s Labour, LibDem and Green groups all criticised the move.

Sheffield street tree campaigners were among those who called for Sheffield to have a different system of council governanceplaceholder image
Sheffield street tree campaigners were among those who called for Sheffield to have a different system of council governance

It’s Our City! said in a statement: “The government is set to force councils to operate under the top down, ‘strong leader’ (leader and cabinet) system. This system led to the disastrous decisions made by Sheffield City Council to cut down healthy street trees and attempt to put citizens in prison for protesting.

“The leader and cabinet system which places decision-making power in the hands of the few was resoundingly rejected by Sheffield voters in our hard-won, citywide referendum in May 2021.

Roughshod

The government’s announcement rides roughshod over the settled will of Sheffielders, and our democratic right to decide the way our council works. In fact the government proposal will remove the rights of people everywhere to decide the way their council works.

Sir Mark Lowcock, chair of the Sheffield street tree inquiry that was heavily critical of Sheffield City Council's actions against protestersplaceholder image
Sir Mark Lowcock, chair of the Sheffield street tree inquiry that was heavily critical of Sheffield City Council's actions against protesters

“Despite Sheffield’s resounding vote for change, the government arrogantly tells us what is best for us, what they will allow us, and how we and our city are to be ‘managed’. We are now only to be allowed the local governance arrangements that suits a government forcing through centralisation of local government into its hands – not the right to choose how our local governance works, that we fought to win, and that we then democratically decided on as a city.

“Sheffield’s position is unique. There is no other council or city where local citizens themselves took collective action, won the right for all the people of Sheffield to decide the way our council works via a citywide referendum, and fought for local governance change to the committee system.

“Our collective and community action in Sheffield was, and remains, the largest ever citizen-led mobilisation in the country demanding local governance change to a committee system.

Tree campaigner Heather Mitchell leaning up against one of the street trees on Meersbrook Park Road, Sheffield that protesters saved from being felledplaceholder image
Tree campaigner Heather Mitchell leaning up against one of the street trees on Meersbrook Park Road, Sheffield that protesters saved from being felled

“The government announcement is not about better ‘devolution’, nor about better local democracy and accountability to local people. The government announcement is about its own ideological preference for so-called ‘strong leaders’ under executive governance systems, and that suits central government not local people.

“This is demonstrated in the exception it makes for the few councils that run with a directly-elected mayor – these arrangements will be allowed to continue. It is also demonstrated in the tired myths and lies about committee governance that the minister’s announcement casually peddles, and that have no basis in fact.

Democratic

“The announcement flies in the face of ‘devolution’ and local democracy, because Sheffield has already made its clear democratic choice known. The government also says it does not want to waste local taxpayers’ money by requiring unnecessary system change, but the opposite is true.

Anne Barr, co-chair of It's Our City! at the Sheffield governance referendum count in May 2021placeholder image
Anne Barr, co-chair of It's Our City! at the Sheffield governance referendum count in May 2021

“It specifically wants to waste local taxpayers’ money in Sheffield to make just such an unnecessary change, when the people of Sheffield have made a clear democratic choice and rejected our failing ‘strong leader’ system.

“We’re not going back, and we want government to recognise and respect Sheffield’s unique position, and the settled democratic will of residents and communities across our city. The reasonable expectation (laid down in 28/08/2025 statute) is that our clear and collective, city-wide referendum decision remains in place for a minimum 10 years.

“And that any attempt, after 10 years, to revert back to more undemocratic, unrepresentative ‘strong leader’ governance must also be supported by a city-wide referendum.

“We recognise the efforts and investment put in by our council to develop Sheffield’s modern committee system. Citizens in Sheffield know that our council has not changed and improved as much as they think they have.

“However, the choice of local committee governance made by Sheffielders has undoubtedly played a key role in the reinvigoration and improvements in our council that we do see.

Positive

“We call on all in our council to defend the settled will of Sheffielders clearly expressed in our local governance referendum, and that was wholly won by Sheffield citizens and communities exercising democratic rights.

“We call on all in our council to defend the positive progress made under Sheffield’s committee governance, to decision-making, and to local democracy and accountability.

“We call on government to recognise the unique position of Sheffield, respect our city’s democratic decision, and to rethink its intended re-imposition of a governance system that failed us in Sheffield.

“We expect government to do far more than simply issue one-size-fits-all edicts according to its own centralising agenda and preferences, and to actually listen to and respect the settled will of the people of Sheffield expressed clearly in a democratic citywide referendum.

“We want government to stop planning for the wholly unnecessary waste of Sheffield taxpayers’ money in a useless and profoundly depressing return to a local governance system local citizens and communities have roundly rejected. To press on would be a profound breach of democratic trust in the face of the settled will of citizens and communities in Sheffield.

“Sheffield can’t go back.”

Legacies

Sheffield Tree Action Group said in a statement: “On the government announcement they will force councils to operate under leader and cabinet governance, and in light of Sheffield’s street tree dispute.

It was the people of Sheffield who acted to oppose and play such a major role in halting the felling of healthy street trees and the abuse of power by Sheffield City Council’s ‘strong leaders’.

“One of the positive legacies of the campaign was that Sheffield residents also subsequently acted collectively and determinedly to force a local referendum that removed destructive ‘strong leader’ governance from our city.

“We are therefore dismayed to see the announcement by government of its intention to force Sheffield to revert back to demonstrably failed and damaging leader and cabinet local governance.

“This will overturn the resounding democratic decision of Sheffield voters in the citywide referendum of May 2021 to get rid of the ‘strong leader’ and establish modern committee governance.

“Any forced reversal of Sheffield’s democratic decision would be a serious error and especially in light of the damage wrought by our council through the street tree dispute.

“STAG urges Sheffield City Council to make the strongest representation possible to government about the need to maintain Sheffield’s committee governance, and for government to rethink.”

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice