Good food hygiene is paramount for restaurants to ensure that their customers are kept safe from food poisoning or other conditions. Food hygiene can be defined as hygienic handling of food, which includes the preparation, cooking, cooling, re-heating and storage. However the Food Standards Agency will also look at the cleanliness and condition of the facilities and building, as well as the management of food safety when carrying out an inspection of a premises.
Italian cuisine is a big hit in Sheffield, with its popularity shown by the many restaurants specialising in all things pizza and pasta. We have taken the highest-rated Italian restaurants on Google to the Food Standards Agency’s website to see how they have been rated.
Every food establishment is given a food hygiene score ranging from zero, meaning urgent improvements are required, up to five, meaning the business fully complies with relevant food laws.
Check out how our city’s top-rated Italian restaurants on Google fare on the food hygiene scale.

9. BB's Italian, Sheffield City Centre
BB's Italian, on Devonshire Street, has been rated 4.7 stars according to 333 reviews on Google. This restaurant was given a food hygiene rating of four after an inspection on July 14, 2022. Photo: Google

10. Appetito, Broomhall
Appetito, on Glossop Road, has a 4.7 star rating, according to 167 reviews by Google users. This Italian restaurant was handed a food hygiene rating of five following an inspection on January 31, 2020. Photo: Google

11. Caffe Piazza, Sheffield City Centre
Caffe Piazza, on Church Street, has been rated 4.6 stars by 581 users on Google. It was handed a food hygiene rating of five following an inspection on June 18, 2019. Photo: Google

12. Nonnas, Sharrow
Nonnas, on Ecclesall Road, is rated 4.5 stars as per 893 reviews on Google. This restaurant was given a food hygiene rating on five at an inspection on July 1, 2021. Photo: Google


