"We want to fully understand what happened" MOJ say after convicted rapist strikes in Sheffield on day release
Government officials want to know why a convicted rapist was granted day release last summer - a decision which allowed him to go on the run and attack a Sheffield woman.
Shockingly, in 2002 when he was allowed out of prison on another community rehabilitation day, he fled from a prison officer who was accompanying him and attacked a woman with a brick in a nearby college.
On Wednesday, February 25, 61-year-old Neil Trennan received his third life sentence after following a woman in Sheffield into her home and attempting to attack her at knifepoint.
The convicted rapist was serving two life sentences for previous violent crimes - including a horrifying rape in Sheffield back in 1990 - when he absconded from HMP North Sea Camp, an open prison in Lincolnshire, and made his way to Sheffield.
In July 2025, he was granted ‘Release on Temporary Licence’ (ROTL), a type of unsupervised day release for prisoners that includes a number of conditions including a time in which they must return to custody.
Trennan didn’t return, instead going on the run for three days during which time he attacked a woman, who was 19 at the time, in her home.


When sentencing him, the Recorder of Sheffield Judge Jeremy Richardson KC, said: “In my judgment it was very unwise to allow you to have any form of unsupervised release given what was known about you.”
The Star contacted the Ministry of Justice (MOJ), who said they want to uncover why the decision to grant Trennan ROTL was passed.
A MOJ spokesperson said: “These were horrendous crimes and our thoughts remain with all the victims affected. Neil Trennan has rightly received the full weight of the law for his actions.
“We will carefully consider the judge’s comments once we receive his letter and are clear that we want to fully understand what happened in this case, including whether any processes or policies need to be strengthened.”
The Government department clarified that the independent parole board recommended transfer of Trennan, to an open prison, which HM Prison and Probation Service (HMPPS) officials accepted after careful consideration.
HMPPS officials make such decisions on behalf of the Secretary of State, and prisoners can be returned to closed convictions if they break the rules or there is evidence of an increased risk.
The MOJ added that those in open prison aren’t automatically entitled to ROTL, and that such releases help offenders from returning to crime.
They said that compliance rates for temporary release conditions are more than 99 per cent.
However, in Sheffield Crown Court during sentencing, Judge Richardson said that he believes evidence from the time - including psychological reports where he disclosed that violence was a trigger for sexual arousal - showed Trennan to be a ‘substantial threat to women’.
He told the court that he hopes the Lord Chancellor, David Lammy MP, conducts an investigation into the situation.
The judge continued: “Having considered the material I have no doubt whatsoever you posed, and continued to pose, a substantial threat to women during 2024 and 2025.
“It is plain you are a sexual deviant who derives enjoyment from sexual violence which heightens you arousal.
“It is against this backdrop of an obvious risk of serious harm and posing a massive danger to women it was an extremely surprising, and potentially wrong, decision that you were transferred to open prison conditions at HMP North Sea Camp.
“I have been given no adequate explanation why this decision was made and this is something which the Lord Chancellor may wish to investigate. I sincerely hope so.
“A mistake was, in my judgment, made. I trust it will never be made again.
“It is astonishing to me that you were permitted to leave the prison in Lincolnshire on an unsupervised basis simply trusting that you would return.”