Judge questions why "sexual deviant" rapist who struck in Sheffield was allowed day release from prison

Sheffield’s leading judge has questioned why a convicted rapist serving two life sentences was allowed unsupervised leave from prison - after he absconded and attempted to attack a university student.

Earlier today (February 25), 61-year-old Neil Trennan was brought into the dock at Sheffield Crown Court to face justice over a horrifying attack at a woman’s home.

On July 10 last year, the convicted rapist - who was serving two life sentences at the time - was given day release from North Sea Camp open prison in Boston, Lincolnshire.

This unsupervised time was granted on the condition that he return to the prison at 1.30pm, however he did not do so.

He was subsequently on the run for three days, in which time he travelled to Sheffield and followed a university student home before brandishing a knife and attempting to assault her.

The Recorder of Sheffield, Judge Jeremy Richardson KC, said he was given 'no adequate explanation' for why a convicted rapist was given day release from prison. The city's top-ranking judge imposed the third life sentence on Neil Trennan, who attempted to attack a woman in her own home after absconding from prisonplaceholder image
The Recorder of Sheffield, Judge Jeremy Richardson KC, said he was given 'no adequate explanation' for why a convicted rapist was given day release from prison. The city's top-ranking judge imposed the third life sentence on Neil Trennan, who attempted to attack a woman in her own home after absconding from prison | Chris Etchells/SYP

The victim - who was 19 at the time - managed to fight off her attacker, and screamed for help at which point he fled.

He later travelled to York where he was caught after being spotted by a member of the public.

However, in passing the third life sentence on Trennan today, the city’s top judge questioned why Trennan was allowed leave in the first place.

“History has repeated itself,” the Recorder of Sheffield, Judge Jeremy Richardson KC said.

“In my judgment it was very unwise to allow you to have any form of unsupervised release given what was known about you.

“I have been given no adequate explanation for the decision. The Lord Chancellor may demand one.”

He went on to say that he hopes the Lord Chancellor - David Lammy MP - conducts an investigation into how this situation occurred.

Trennan was previously convicted for raping a woman in Sheffield after knocking her unconscious with a dumbbell in 1990.

He hit the woman around 12 times during the assault, causing serious injuries.

Then in 2002 he received his second life sentence for hitting a woman with a brick.

The second incident took place in Norwich, with Trennan on escorted leave in the city centre before fleeing from a prison guard. He made his way to a local college and followed his victim into the bathroom before the attack.

He had previous sexual offence convictions dating back to the 1980s, including reports of acts of voyeurism.

Psychological reports created while he was in prison - which were read out at court during sentencing - detail how he continued to have violent fantasies and was aroused by ‘violent, non-consenting sex’.

As late as July 2024, Trennan had told a Community Offender Manager that violence was a trigger for sexual arousal, it was said in court.

The judge continued: “Having considered the material I have no doubt whatsoever you posed, and continued to pose, a substantial threat to women during 2024 and 2025.

“It is plain you are a sexual deviant who derives enjoyment from sexual violence which heightens you arousal.

“It is against this backdrop of an obvious risk of serious harm and posing a massive danger to women it was an extremely surprising, and potentially wrong, decision that you were transferred to open prison conditions at HMP North Sea Camp.

“I have been given no adequate explanation why this decision was made and this is something which the Lord Chancellor may wish to investigate. I sincerely hope so.

“A mistake was, in my judgment, made. I trust it will never be made again.

“It is astonishing to me that you were permitted to leave the prison in Lincolnshire on an unsupervised basis simply trusting that you would return.”

The Ministry of Justice has been approached for comment.

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice