‘Out! Everyone Out!’: Top Sheffield judge scolds families of acquitted men for celebrating in public gallery

"Out! Everyone out!" stormed the judge, slamming the file in front of him shut. "I won't have this, everyone out.”

The families of two men acquitted of attempted murder were thrown out of court this week by the Recorder of Sheffield His Honour Judge Jeremy Richardson, as they began cheering and clapping at the moment the case was formally discharged.placeholder image
The families of two men acquitted of attempted murder were thrown out of court this week by the Recorder of Sheffield His Honour Judge Jeremy Richardson, as they began cheering and clapping at the moment the case was formally discharged. | SYP, Iconic Media Group, Chris Etchells

The families of the two men found not guilty of attempted murder this week probably never pictured being thrown out of court at their moment of victory.

After days of intricate legal arguments, The Recorder of Sheffield His Honour Judge Jeremy Richardson ruled on Tuesday (November 17) he had no choice but to stop the trial of Raheel Mahmood and Samin Khan and acquit them both.

The families of two men acquitted of attempted murder were thrown out of court this week by the Recorder of Sheffield His Honour Judge Jeremy Richardson, as they began cheering and clapping at the moment the case was formally discharged.placeholder image
The families of two men acquitted of attempted murder were thrown out of court this week by the Recorder of Sheffield His Honour Judge Jeremy Richardson, as they began cheering and clapping at the moment the case was formally discharged. | SYP, Iconic Media Group, Chris Etchells

They faced charges of allegedly shooting a young man in the chest, who as a result lost the use of both his legs and one arm.

"As the trial proceeded, I became more concerned that the case was nowhere near as cogent as before," said the judge in his ruling.

“The reason being the identification and recognition evidence you have heard is not of a strong character at all - in fact, it is quite weak."

After dismissing the jury, he turned to tell the defendants - who have been in custody for over 10 months - the words they've been waiting for.

"For all the reasons who have heard, you are discharged," began Judge Richardson.

The two men's families in the packed public gallery will have wanted to be there when the ruling was made.

Unfortunately, that’s when they started clapping and cheering.

"Out! Everyone out!" stormed the judge, slamming the file in front of him shut. "I won't have this, everyone out. I will be back in five minutes."

And so, in what should have been a moment of family solidarity, none of Khan or Mahmood’s supporters were in the gallery to see them formally found not guilty.

“Why would you start clapping?” said a clearly exasperated Mahmood to his friends and family as they were led out - all it had done was delay when he would be released from custody. Furthermore, now His Honour was offended.

I can’t say I’ve never seen anything like it - I’ve seen many people thrown out of court, and for much less. Even muttering to a family member will do it. Or walking in too loudly.

But it’s a rare thing to see an entire public gallery break court decorum and assume it would be justice for them to celebrate the verdict they wanted. But that’s just not the case.

“It was outrageous a few minutes ago when supporters of yours clapped,” said the judge to just the two of them on his return.

“This is not a case for clapping or rejoicing.

“A young man was shot and grievously injured.

“Whoever is responsible has committed very serious crimes, and in this case it could not be proved it was you.

“I emphasise - it could not be proved it was you.

“In this country, we operate by the rule of law, not disorder.

“This is not a case for rejoicing.”

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice