The three quick changes Sheffield could make to boost city centre footfall ahead of Christmas

Is Sheffield doing enough to increase footfall in the city centre?

As December is almost here and people are getting ahead of their Christmas shopping - it should be the busiest time of year for city centre businesses.

However, with limited initiatives launched to encourage people to visit these business, we question what is actually being done stimulate footfall in the run up to Christmas?

Fargate, Sheffield City Centre | The Star is calling for three quick changes to be made to improve footfall in the city centre.placeholder image
Fargate, Sheffield City Centre | The Star is calling for three quick changes to be made to improve footfall in the city centre. | Iconic

So we took to the streets, from High Street to Division Street, to speak with shoppers and independent businesses about what they would like to see to try and get more people through their doors over the festive period.

While out and about, one shopper used the term “tumbleweed city” - citing limited accessible travel options that are affordable for everyone as the reason for low numbers of customers.

So we are calling for these three changes that could be implemented throughout December to increase footfall in the city and support our local shops at a time when they should be thriving.

Parking

There is limited free parking available close to the city centre. The car parks seem to fill quickly and when you do get lucky enough to find a space, the prices are extortionate.

This can be reason enough to discourage shoppers - buying Christmas presents can already be expensive and so having to pay money for a trip that might not even take longer than an hour means people choose to shop in places like Meadowhall, where there is free parking.

Jill Winton, 57, has lived in Sheffield for 30 years, she founded Plantology on Division Street - a small, independent florist selling beautiful flowers and plants.

Jill Winton, 57, founder of Plantology on Division Street.placeholder image
Jill Winton, 57, founder of Plantology on Division Street. | Iconic

She said she thinks it is “very difficult for people getting into Sheffield” and suggested that free parking would be beneficial to local businesses.

She said: “Even 20 or 40 minutes of free parking would be good to encourage people to come into the city centre.

“We also need more shops, it would be nice to have more shops to bring people in - more diverse retail. I think Sheffield’s always lacked behind other cities like Leeds and Manchester.”

Plantology on Division Street is a small, independent florist with a team that shares their love for the natural world with anyone who chooses to enter the shop.placeholder image
Plantology on Division Street is a small, independent florist with a team that shares their love for the natural world with anyone who chooses to enter the shop. | Iconic

We hear time-and-time again about the parking situation but understand full-time free parking isn’t always possible. However, if council car parks could be free on every Saturday throughout December for example, this would be a huge incentive for people to come and spend their money on the many independent stores Sheffield has to offer.

Steven Magill, 67, thinks that most people tend to shop at Meadowhall instead of the city centre. placeholder image
Steven Magill, 67, thinks that most people tend to shop at Meadowhall instead of the city centre. | Iconic

Steven Magill, 67, said: “With Meadowhall being so close, people go there - there really isn’t enough in the centre apart from the Christmas markets.”

Stuart Mcadie, 59, owns The Alternative store, an independent streetwear shop located on Division Street.

He said: “Things like free parking will always benefit people, we’re always competing with Meadowhall for accessibility, so things like that would be beneficial.”

Stuart Mcadie owns The Alternative Store on Division Street - a unique, independent store that sells casual streetwear clothing.placeholder image
Stuart Mcadie owns The Alternative Store on Division Street - a unique, independent store that sells casual streetwear clothing. | Iconic

Bus gates

Bus gates are something else that seem to be causing disruption for people travelling in and out of the city centre.

Their intended purpose is to improve public transport and supposedly make it easier for people to travel around - however this doesn’t seem to be the case.

Just last month, hundreds of people in Hillsborough signed a petition against proposals to introduce a new 12 hour bus gate in the area.

Individuals raised the alarm that shutting down road access would make it harder for customers to get to their store, impacting trading for local businesses.

Laura Butler, 60, from Hillsborough said that travel routes into Sheffield “need to be more accessible” so traffic can be more “free flowing”.

She said: “I think the council have put bus gates everywhere, it’s inaccessible.”

Laura even called Sheffield a “tumbleweed city” due to the lack of incentives encouraging people in.

Public transport

With the ongoing disruptions on the blue route of the city’s tram network after a well was discovered under the tracks near Birley Lane in August, it means that many people between Gleadless and Halfway have to find alternative routes into the centre.

In our monthly Q+A with South Yorkshire Mayor Oliver Coppard, he revealed that this problem is not likely to be fixed this year.

Businesses highlight this as a reason for shoppers not being able to get into Sheffield. While it is understood this is not a quick fix, it does contribute to the lack of Christmas shopping in the centre.

In addition, it would be helpful to see prices of tram tickets reduced during December as an incentive, it has been suggested.

Jodie Paylin, from Mosborough, works at Glass Onion, a vintage clothing store on Division Street.

Jodie Paylin highlighted how parts of the Supertram route only operate in one part of the city at the moment, which can be a "struggle" for people wanting to travel into the centre to do their Christmas shopping. placeholder image
Jodie Paylin highlighted how parts of the Supertram route only operate in one part of the city at the moment, which can be a "struggle" for people wanting to travel into the centre to do their Christmas shopping. | Iconic

She said: “Trams at the moment are running on one side of the city, that’s a struggle. If they could bring in something to encourage the use of other transport that would be good.”

She highlighted how despite this, their store does get busier around Christmas and “expect a lot of people” as December approaches.

Glass Onion is a popular vintage clothing store located on Division Street in Sheffield City Centre.placeholder image
Glass Onion is a popular vintage clothing store located on Division Street in Sheffield City Centre. | Iconic

When we asked what things people would change to encourage more people into the city centre, Mark Roberts said: “Decent travel options like getting the tram back running to Halfway.”

A South Yorkshire Mayoral Combined Authority spokesperson said: "We want to make it as easy as possible for people to use public transport to enjoy South Yorkshire over Christmas. We're currently working through our festive Supertram plans and will be sharing more details very soon, including extra Supertram services to help people get around during the busy Christmas period."

What are other cities doing?

According to ‘worldometer’, Sheffield is the sixth biggest city in England by population - so why are we so behind in initiatives for the Christmas period?

In Manchester, new pop-up parking spaces have been introduced while overnight restrictions on Park & Ride spaces have been lifted.

In Leeds, parking fares have been scrapped in five town centres after a public consultation was held with the council. Now they are urging people to support businesses and to shop local.

Even in smaller, rural communities like the High Peak, they have considered the busiest time of year, and have launched free parking on council car parks across market town centres.

When we looked at what out neighbours are doing in South Yorkshire, we actually found that Barnsley and Rotherham have free parking options all year round in specific locations.

So if other places can do it, why can’t Sheffield?

The importance of supporting local businesses is also recognised by Sheffield BID, a partnership that funds projects and services to improve the city.

They said: “The run-up to Christmas is hugely important for Sheffield city centre businesses and the wider local economy. There is already a significant amount of activity taking place to support Christmas trading this year, with a programme of festive events, attractions and initiatives designed to give people more reasons to visit and enjoy the city centre.

“There is no single solution or silver bullet when it comes to increasing city centre footfall. Our focus is on building and promoting a compelling proposition for Sheffield – creating reasons for people to visit, encouraging them to stay longer and making the most of everything the city has to offer. This requires a collective effort from businesses and stakeholders across the city.

“Measures around parking and public transport are part of the wider conversation about accessibility, but it is important that any proposals are considered in terms of their practicality, cost, and demonstrable impact. Ultimately, our priority is to encourage more people to choose Sheffield city centre and to support the businesses that make it what it is.”

What is Sheffield doing?

As we call for more to be done to increase footfall in the city, it’s important to look at what Sheffield is currently doing.

  • A notable example is the free bus service, Sheffield Connect, which provides free travel for everyone around the city, running seven days a week.
  • The business pop-up store has returned to Leah’s Yard - giving around 50 Sheffield businesses the opportunity to showcase and sell their products in the run up to Christmas.
  • The Christmas trail is a family initiative designed to support footfall across the city centre. It encourages movement between participating businesses and locations, prompting trading for local shops.
  • Sheffield Gift Cards are available to buy online and are accepted by more than 80 city centre businesses - with the aim to shop local.
  • The classic Christmas markets are also a good example of attempting to bring people into the city and run right up until Christmas Eve.

So whilst there are some initiatives in place, the major concerns people have, don’t seem to be directly addressed - and compared to other cities, Sheffield could do better.

We have approached the council to comment, but they have chosen not to respond.

With Christmas just around the corner, Sheffield’s challenge is clear - give people more reasons to shop in the city centre and support local businesses.

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice