'My cat's blood is on your hands, yours will be on mine' - Sheffield man sent threatening messages to family
A man who suffered a ‘catastrophic decline in mental health’ after the death of his cat spent months threatening violence against relatives he blamed for the loss, a court heard.
“I’m going to slit your f***ing throat,” David Holmes said in a text message to his sister-in-law during a near six-month-long campaign of threats in 2025.
The consistent tirade began after the 42-year-old, of Norton Lees Road, blamed both his younger brother and sister-in-law for the death of his cat.
He was living with the couple when his cat escaped from the house and was run over.
![David Holmes, 42 of Norton Lees Road, spent months sending threatening messages to his relatives after the death of his cat. In one incident, he threatened to burn down their home, and in another said: "[My cat's] blood is on your hands, and your blood is going to be on mine." (Stock image)](https://www.thestar.co.uk/jpim-static/image/2026/04/10/8/51/Your-paragraph-text-(43).jpeg?crop=3:2,smart&trim=&width=640&quality=65)

Holmes accusing his relatives of letting his pet out.
Neil Coxon, prosecuting, told Sheffield Crown Court, Holmes had sufferd with his mental health, but this incident ‘brought it to a head’ and in the following months he became increasingly distressed.
The victims explained how he began slamming doors, playing loud music and screaming loudly.
“[Complainant one] notes that the defendant seemed to take the death of the cat particularly badly and she initially put down his change in behaviour to this,” Mr Coxon continued.
By January 2025 things had escalated, with Holme’s sister-in-law finding a wooden chopping board with around 100 ‘deep stab marks’ in it.
The couple also found a ‘beheaded’ toy and a ring of candles in their room, which were set out in a ‘ritual fashion’.
Holmes began sending threatening messages, the court heard, accusing his relatives of killing his ‘little boy’ and writing: “[My cat’s] blood is on your hands and your blood is going to be on mine.”
“This threat was extremely scary for me - I had a severe panic attack,” a statement from one of the victims, read out in court by Mr Coxon, added.
There were lulls in the messages, the court was told, followed by further threats, with one victim adding: “As all of these incidents have been so spaced apart I seem to get better and then something else happens which causes me now to be in a constant state of panic.
“I’m scared he is going to see me on my commute, turn up at work, or find out where we might live as he has now made a threat to burn our house down to my partner.
“I’m having to undergo therapy now and can see myself being affected for a long time to come.”
The court heard Holmes’ relationship with his brother was now ‘completely over’.
When interviewed by police, Holmes gave a full account and said the offending was due to his mental health issues.
He pleaded guilty to two counts of harassment.
It was explained that Holmes grew up in a religious cult that saw him move through different nations regularly as local authorities attempted to ban the group’s activities.
It was said in court that there were reports of physical abuse in the cult, which is understood to have caused ‘complex PTSD’.
Vanessa Saxton, representing Holmes, a former chef, said he had been seeking support for his mental health.
The court was also told that Holmes had since got another cat.
Sentencing Holmes, Recorder Mark Giuliani said: “You grew up in some sort of cult [...] as a result of which you and your family spent your childhood moving around from country to country.
“I’m satisfied it has left a deep, untreated emotional scar on you and that deep emotional scar is reflected in your generally poor mental health.
“I’m satisfied that your mental health has impacted your ability to cope with stress, your ability to cope with what happened when you were living with your brother and his partner.”
Holmes was placed on a community order for two years, with up to 40 days rehabilitation activity and 150 hours’ unpaid work.
A restraining order barring Holmes from communicating with the two victims ‘by any means whatsoever’ was also put in place for a period of 10 years.