Andrew Smith MBE: Tributes to “scrupulously fair-minded” Sheffield judge who passed away after short illness

The professional life of a Sheffield barrister and judge known for being “scrupulously fair-minded” has been honoured in a special court hearing, after he passed away at the age of 62 following a short illness.

With every available seat taken in the courtroom, from barristers’ benches, to the jury box, public gallery and dock, it was standing room only as eulogies to Andrew Smith MBE were delivered at Sheffield Crown Court today (Monday, December 8, 2025).

Andrew passed away on November 29, 2025, following what has been described as a “sudden and unexpected illness.”

With every available seat taken in the courtroom, from barristers’ benches, to the jury box, public gallery and dock, it was standing room only as eulogies to Andrew Smith MBE were delivered at Sheffield Crown Court today (Monday, December 8, 2025)placeholder image
With every available seat taken in the courtroom, from barristers’ benches, to the jury box, public gallery and dock, it was standing room only as eulogies to Andrew Smith MBE were delivered at Sheffield Crown Court today (Monday, December 8, 2025) | Picture courtesy of Bank House Chambers

Born and educated in Manchester, Andrew, like so many others, arrived in the city as a student at the University of Sheffield before making a life here. Following his graduation, Andrew joined the then Paradise Square Chambers, with Jeremy Baker, now Lord Justice Baker KC, as his Pupil Master, before going on to join Bank House, formerly Bank Street, Chambers upon his completion of pupillage.

In one of two eulogies, delivered to those present within the packed courtroom, as well as to several more attending remotely, Head of Chambers at Bank House, Katherine Goddard KC, said Andrew’s appointment to the firm in the early ‘90s was seen as a “bit of a coup.”

Ms Goddard said the life experience Andrew brought to Bank House, the oldest independent set of chambers outside of London, due to starting his law career a little later in life was regarded as an asset from the offset.

“Andrew settled ‘into chambers’ immediately and became - and remained - such a central plank to the identity of Bank House…that many of us struggle to remember a time when Andrew was not at Bank House Chambers, even after taking on his judicial appointments,” she said.

Andrew was a well-liked barrister, and was for a time, an almost permanent fixture at Sheffield Crown Court before taking to the judge’s bench as a Recorder at the court in 2020.

More recently, Andrew combined his professional passions of the military and judiciary by serving as an Assistant Judge Advocate General from 2021, through to the time of his sudden death.

Through his role as an Assistant Judge Advocate General, Andrew was assigned to the Courts Martial sitting in Catterick, North Yorkshire where he was said to have “established a reputation for fairness and efficiency and became a popular tribunal among members.”

Ms Goddard described being “grateful” to have shared just a small part of Andrew’s life through their time together in chambers.

She thanked his wife Michelle, and sons Matthew and Henry, all of whom were present in court, for “sharing him with us.”

Andrew, or ‘Smithy,’ as he was known to many, had two professional settings, Ms Goddard said, with the first being a “beaming grin” for all those he encountered.

The second could be detected through a facial expression “like thunder,” she told the packed courtroom.

“Andrew always had a joke to make, or a prank to pull,” Ms Goddard said, although she was keen to stress neither would ever be at the expense of those “more vulnerable.”

“Impeccably” dressed Andrew was “the best role model for any aspiring barrister,” Ms Goddard said.

She described him as being a dedicated supporter of the “Junior Bar,” and the trainee barristers within its ranks, to whom he was “always willing to offer wisdom and experience.”

The Recorder of Sheffield, Judge Jeremy Richardson KC, also delivered a eulogy, describing Andrew as someone who was “scrupulously fair-minded.”

Judge Richardson continued: “He was a man filled with integrity, he was also a brave man…I, like everyone here, mourn his death. He died far too young, and we will miss him very much.”

“He was an immensely likeable man, and we are so much the poorer now he is no longer with us.”

“He was always a worthy and capable opponent.”

Judge Richardson said Andrew was uniquely well-placed to serve as an Assistant Judge Advocate General, due to the twin pillars of his professional life formed of the judiciary and his service in the Territorial Army (TA), where he rose to the rank of Lieutenant Colonel.

During his time in the TA, Andrew was deployed to Bosnia as part of the United Kingdom’s contribution to the peacekeeping mission following the fall of the former Yugoslavia.

Andrew led the only TA regiment deployed to Bosnia, and was awarded with an MBE for his contribution during that period, before receiving the Territorial Decoration for his long standing dedication to the TA.

Judge Richardson said Andrew was like many servicemen who “served in difficult theatres of conflict” in that he rarely spoke of that period of his life.

But whilst he did not “dwell” on that period, Andrew was able to use his understanding and experiences of service, and “fair-minded” approach to cases, in his role as an Assistant Judge Advocate General.

“Because of his own military service, he commanded the respect of the court, and those before it,” said Judge Richardson.

“He was scrupulously fair-minded and interested in the vagaries of life, and the challenges faced by those in military service, as well as ordinary civilians.”

“His innate sense of fairness shone through, his integrity was paramount, and [enabled him] just to do the job so well.”

Judge Richardson said of Andrew’s family life: “He loved his family beyond compare, and they loved him.”

He also spoke of the pride Andrew felt in seeing his sons join the RAF cadets.

A tribute issued by Bank House Chambers, published on their website, states: “Andrew will be sorely missed by all who knew him and by the many friends he made in the Army, on the Bench and in Chambers.

“But it [is] his family who will feel his loss most acutely and it is with them that our thoughts and prayers will remain.”

A further eulogy to Andrew is set to be delivered at Catterick on Thursday (December 11, 2025).

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice