BB's Italian Restaurant, on Devonshire Street, in Sheffield city centre, was established in 1999. It has a 4.7 star average score from 388 Google reviews.placeholder image
BB's Italian Restaurant, on Devonshire Street, in Sheffield city centre, was established in 1999. It has a 4.7 star average score from 388 Google reviews. | Google

The top 15 Italian restaurants in Sheffield according to Google, including Piccolos and Rudy’s Pizza

It’s one of the nation’s favourite cuisines, and Sheffield certainly 

While the sunshine seems to have disappeared, we can still be transported to the Mediterranean with dozens of fantastic Italian restaurants in Sheffield.

From pasta and pizza, to aubergine parmigiana, arancini, bruschetta and caprese salad, there really is something for everyone. 

We have scoured through Google to find the best Italians in the city according to those that have tried and tested the venues. 

Below we’ve listed 15 of the top Italians, sorted in ascending order of star rating on Google.

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice