Its favourite places including what it calls ‘local gems’, which are recognised for offering ‘value for money, informal settings and delicious cooking’.
There are seven of these ‘local gems’ in Sheffield, from much-loved stalwarts of the city’s culinary scene to some amazing newcomers.
These highly-rated venues are listed below, with details of what The Good Food Critics loved at each, what The Star thought, and what the general public makes of them, based on Google reviews.
September is Food and Drink month in The Star, where we are championing the city’s hospitality industry.

5. Tonco Bakery
Tonco Bakery, on Sharrow Vale Road, Sheffield, is the sister venue of the sadly closed Tonco restaurant. The Good Food Guide dubbed it a 'very worthy coffee-and-cake pit stop', and also praised the short brunch/lunch menu. Tonco Bakery has a 4.8/5 rating from 57 Google reviews, with customers praising the 'amazing' coffee and the 'fresh and delicious' food. | Google Photo: Google

6. Tamper at Sellers Wheel
Tamper Coffee is housed in Sellers Wheel, a former silversmiths on Arundel Gate in Sheffield city centre. The Kiwi café has a popular and inventive breakfast and brunch menu, with dishes including salt beef benedict, chilli crab scramble, and Turkish eggs. The Good Food Guide hailed the crisp halloumi with zhoug dressing, coconut togarashi and puffed rice, and the corn fritters with goji berries, charcoal yoghurt and crunchy corn. It called Tamper a 'dream spot' for vegetarians but one that would not disappoint meat eaters. It also praised the 'great' coffee, the fresh juices and the pastries and cakes. The Star's reviewer loved the full English there. | National World Photo: Tony Johnson

7. Urban Choola
Urban Choola, on Ecclesall Road, which was crowned Best Sheffield Restaurant at the British Restaurant Awards 2024, is another of the Good Food Guide's 'local gems'. The guide loved the 'good-value food backed by warm, welcoming service'. Urban Choola is Sheffield’s top-rated restaurant on Tripadvisor, with a perfect 5.0 star rating, and many diners have claimed it serves the ‘best curry in Sheffield’. It also boasts an impressive 4.5-star Google rating, with one diner praising the ‘beautiful food, delightfully crafted'. Top dishes include the Hyderabadi lamb biryani and the Kodampuli Malabar Prawn, made with king prawns, coconut and a mouthwatering blend of Keralan spices. | Google/National World Photo: Google/National World

8. Bragazzi's
Bragazzi's delicatessen & cafe, on Sheffield's bustling Abbeydale Road, was hailed by the Good Food Guide for serving up the 'best of Italian produce', from cakes to panini with delicious cheeses and cured meats. It has a 4.8/5 rating from 575 Google reviews, with one fan calling it a 'lovely little cafe with warm Italian vibes and proper good coffee'. | Google Photo: Google

