Best pubs Sheffield: Hillsborough pubs rated by YouTube stars, from sweary boozer to 'perfect' 10/10

YouTube stars on a mission to visit every pub in the UK have given their verdict on the watering holes of Hillsborough in Sheffield.

The couple behind The Great British Pub Crawl found some real gems when they visited the Sheffield suburb, but not every boozer got the thumbs up.

And in one they found the locals so sweary hardly any of the footage they shot inside could be used.

Dale Harvey and his wife Holly have been touring the nation’s pubs and sharing their honest reviews on their hit YouTube account and Facebook page.

They were in Hillsborough last week, and visited an impressive 15 pubs in one day, sampling the beers and meeting the punters, staff and landlords.

The New Barrack Tavern, on Penistone Road, Hillsborough, Sheffieldplaceholder image
The New Barrack Tavern, on Penistone Road, Hillsborough, Sheffield | Google

One of their favourites was the New Barrack Tavern, on Penistone Road, which they described as a ‘real 10/10’, with Dale calling it the ‘perfect way to end my night’.

They were full of praise for the tenants, who they said had been there for 22 years and are ‘amazing’ people who are ‘so friendly’.

They described how the pub had the biggest ale line-up of the day and there was ‘so much going on’, including, on the night they visited, a ukulele group. They loved the pub’s ‘rustic charm’ and its ‘amazing’ beer garden with a stage for music and comedy.

Dale and Holly also loved The Queens Ground, calling it a ‘top, top pub’ in a ‘stunning building’ with a ‘great little beer garden’ and ‘absolutely lovely’ managers.

The Queens Ground pub, on Langsett Road, Hillsborough, Sheffieldplaceholder image
The Queens Ground pub, on Langsett Road, Hillsborough, Sheffield | Google

Another of their favourites was the ‘awesome’ Hillsborough Tap, which they said had a great range of cask and keg beers, and a ‘lovely vibe’.

The Pangolin craft beer bar, on Middlewood Road, got the thumbs up too, with Dale calling it an ‘absolute belter of an establishment with beers that could have kept me entertained all night’.

And the Old Crown, on Penistone Road, he said was another ‘belter’ of a pub, where you wander in and ‘feel like you've been a regular for years’.

The Beer House, Dale said, had a ‘brilliant’ selection of craft beers and some ‘fantastic’ cask ales on offer, The Riverside was a ‘proper salt of the earth, friendly place’ and The Shakey he called a ‘nice looking old school boozer with (a) friendly way about it’.

The Masons Arms, Dale said, was a ‘great little locals pub’, The Northern Monkey he called a ‘superb little micropub with stylish decor and a friendly welcome’, and The Beekeeper, he said, was a ‘lovely little pub’ owned by a ‘lovely fella’.

The Castle, Dale said, was a ‘lovely looking pub with a couple of decent ales on and good old school look about it’. But he said it felt very much like a ‘locals’ local’, with so much swearing going on at the bar that he had to cut most of the footage!

Dale and Holly’s trip to Hillsborough was not the first time they have sampled the pubs of Sheffield.

Dale previously experienced the delights of Abbeydale Road, where he found another two ‘10/10’ pubs among the many he visited.

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice