These are the best places in Sheffield for a roast pork sandwich - according to the people who live here
These are the outlets recommended for a great pork sandwich by our readers
Sheffield is a city populated by a number of shops, delis, butchers and bakers that each deliver a wide-range of fantastic sandwiches.
Recently, the Star set off on a quest across the Steel City to crown our favourite pork sandwich. We tried sandwiches from three of the city’s favourite outlets and gave our verdict
However our taste test was only that of a limited sample range, and we know this topic is hugely subjective, so we put the question to our readers. Where’s your favourite hot roast pork sarnie from?
After letting the comments accumulate and also receiving some tip-offs over email, we have gathered some of your suggestions for places to go for a decent pork sandwich.
Spoiler alert, we are fortunate enough to have so much choice when it comes to places to get a great sandwich for lunch. Choice is always a fortunate thing, but also we are really fortunate to be able to get your suggestions to share too.
“I live in Hillsborough, which is not only home to the Béres factory shop, but is also home to two wonderful pork shops - Lily's on Penistone Road and also F.F Funks Pork Butchers on Middlewood Road. Pop and try those too!” said Irene W.
Lily’s came up a few times, with Mark W saying: “Lily's on Penistone Road gets my vote every time!”.
Neil H also chimed in with: “Lily’s. I like Béres, but Lily’s in Owlerton are my fave.”


One of the other places that came with a bunch of recommendations was F Funks Butchers. David P said it was “the best” while Trisha W and Steve C both suggested it, although Steve C added that Béres is also a good choice.
“In Hillsborough, 1 Funk's, 2 Helen's, 3 Porky Lil's,” said Richard L. In his ranking of his top three, Helens was mentioned and it has proven to be a popular choice among our readers.


That wasn’t the only praise for Helens with Leon W and Michael L both recommending the long-running Hillsborough bakery (formerly known as Biltons).
Shane B had a word of warning for those trying a pork sandwich from Helens, though, saying: “Be warned, it’s a messy one, but it's one of the best in my opinion. Chunky swathes of pork, I don't think they even own a meat slicer! But it's so nice!”


However, John H disagreed, stating that he preferred Béres. A lot of people are a fans of this Sheffield pork sandwich shop chain which has expanded all across the city.
Dennis W commented on the post that he chooses Béres every time. And the positive comments kept coming, with some calling it “the best” while others said it will never be beaten.
We also had a number of recommendations for roast pork sandwiches from a variety of city butchers.
Ian R recommends Thickitts the butchers on Sharrow Vale Road for the sheer amount of filling you get.
John Crawshaw's Butchers also got its fair share of plaudits and praise.
Elsewhere, there was praise for Barkers the Bakers. Wayne M said it was “the best” which is an opinion shared by a number of commenters, with at least ten more people recommending the bakers for a solid pork sandwich fix.
.jpeg?crop=3:2,smart&trim=&width=640&quality=65)

In the city-centre, Staniforths also has its share of fans. Andrew W sent in an email saying that the popular South Yorkshire family baker on Chapel Walk should be our next try - and we may just take him up on that.
Another thumbs up for Staniforths on Chapel Walk said that it was the “best in town”. Martin RH chimed in with another endorsement for the traditional family bakery.
“Queens Road B&Q carpark, food van pork sandwich is definitely one of best,” says Dale F with a slightly more left-field suggestion.
But Dawn G responding to Dale said: “True, I love their pork sarnies. Proper shredded roast pork, probably from pork shoulder, unlike the ham or gammon kind Béres and other shops may sell. Half the price and bigger too.”
Another shout out came from Tom B, who said that we need to “try Liberty Foods in Totley”. Tom’s suggestion got a thumbs up from Nick B, who added: “that’s the best one.”


Richard B went straight to a pub, saying: “Best pork sarnies are The Commercial pub on Station Road, Chapeltown, on a Saturday evening. If you go in about 9pm, chef brings out big pork joint on the bar carves it and puts it in big bread cake with all the trimmings beautiful they are.” How can we resist?
What is clear is that there is a fantastic collection of places to get a really good roast pork sarnie across the city. We received hundreds of suggestions and comments from readers who each took the time to recommend a variety of places. Honourable mentions too to the likes of Dolly's in Beighton and Jo's in Woodhouse, Cup&Crumb Cafe on Madehurst Road and The Butchers Block & Deli in Chapeltown.
There’s not quite an out-and-out victor here, but that’s not such a bad thing. It’s great to see a wide-range of places to visit for a decent roast pork sandwich across the city and plenty to add to our list of places to try.