We went on a mission to discover Sheffield’s ‘best pork sarnie’ - this is what we found

I had a craving and went on a mission

I recently found myself craving a proper roast pork sandwich but didn’t know where was best to go.

Fortunately Sheffield is a city full of fantastic sandwich shops as well as the legendary Béres. So, I went and visited a few to see what they had on offer.

When it comes to a quality pork sandwich, you could be forgiven for automatically thinking of Béres. And for good reason. The iconic sandwich shop is renowned across Sheffield (and even further afield) for its classic Yorkshire hot roast pork sandwich.

To many it is undeniably the best, but that’s not a view shared by everyone when it comes to the elite roast pork sandwich and that’s ok. Choice is undoubtedly a fine thing.

Cue the excuse for this scientific endeavour… Oklay, I’ll be honest, I just wanted to eat a bunch of sandwiches and write about them!

For the purpose of being fair and balanced, I also roped in the services of The Star’s Joe Cawthorn to provide his views in this foodie test.

You only need to look at the queues that regularly form outside Sheffield Béres shops to know that people here to consider it to be the best place in the city to get a pork sandwichplaceholder image
You only need to look at the queues that regularly form outside Sheffield Béres shops to know that people here to consider it to be the best place in the city to get a pork sandwich | Local Library

My first stop took me to the Ecclesall Road branch of Béres.

Established back in 1961. It is seen as a staple of the city’s sandwich scene and often rataes highly with food reviewers, influencers, and the general public.

With 14-branches across the city, there are plenty of places to pick up one of its signature sarnies or one of many of its delicious savouries and deli sandwich options.

At each of the sandwich shops visited, we ordered one of the regular/standard sized roast pork sandwiches along with all of the trimmings that come with it.

Coming in at a pretty decent £4.20, Béres’ hot roast pork sandwich is served in a homemade bread cake, home cooked pork dripping, pork crackling, thinly sliced pork, sage & onion stuffing and apple sauce.

Joe gave the first verdict on this sandwich:

“The mixture of texture, the crispiness of the crackling and the added extras, from the apple sauce to the stuffing, complement it really well. Then you have the pork that falls apart in your mouth.

“Bread's often not mentioned in these things, but I think this breads really good. It's got that sort of bite to it. You have to really cut through. Overall, really good.”

I agree with Joe’s take here, I found the Béres version to be delicious.

The dripping soaked bread is soft and fluffy complementing the thin slices of pork, marrying up really well with the stuffing and apple sauce. The crackling is smashed up into smaller chunks, it’s nice and crunchy but with a chewiness to it – very well balanced.

Roses The Bakers has five shops spread out across the city. A family-run business since the 1940s, it is a bit of a Sheffield institution. Its hot roast pork sandwiches are worth definitely worth a trip thereplaceholder image
Roses The Bakers has five shops spread out across the city. A family-run business since the 1940s, it is a bit of a Sheffield institution. Its hot roast pork sandwiches are worth definitely worth a trip there | Iconic Media

Moving onto the next sandwich, this one comes from Roses The Bakers, which has five shops spread out across the city.

A family-run business since the 1940s, it is a bit of a Sheffield institution.

The pork sandwich from here features a bread cake filled with slices of freshly cooked medium to chunky sliced pork loin, with apple sauce, stuffing and crackling.

What was immediately noticeable was the chunky apple pieces in the sauce, and the pork wasn’t as salty as what Béres produces, without being negative. It was tasty and personally more to my taste. The stuffing spread marries well with the crackling, which is crispy and not at all tough or overly chewy.

For £4.65, it’s 45p more than Béres’ sarnie but it’s definitely worth it.

Roses The Bakers has five shops spread out across the city. A family-run business since the 1940s, it is a bit of a Sheffield institution. Its hot roast pork sandwiches are worth definitely worth a trip there.placeholder image
Roses The Bakers has five shops spread out across the city. A family-run business since the 1940s, it is a bit of a Sheffield institution. Its hot roast pork sandwiches are worth definitely worth a trip there. | Iconic Media

And last but by no means least, Banner Crust serves up a very tasty pork sandwich.

At £4.30, Banner Crust is very much the middle-ground of all three in terms of pricing but the quality levels throughout remained impeccable.

Joe said that the bread cake immediately felt thicker, more substantial and you’ve your usual fillings, stuffing, crackling, pork apple sauce.

“The first thing to note is the apple sauce, it’s much more tangy. Tart, like cider. It has a much more acidic-sort of nature,” he said.

“The bread helps with this, it feels thicker and gives more of a chew. The others felt a little like they were much softer. This is more pillowy in texture.”

He really liked it.

After making our way through three very tasty, filling and impressive pork sandwiches it’s time for the final verdict.

Joe made his choice first: “Crackling is puffier, loads of pork in it. A really good amount of pork in it. Maybe the best amount of pork to condiment ratio, which as we know is really important when it comes to these scientific tests.

“Overall, the salt to tang ratio of the pork and apple sauce is really good. This one stands out when it comes to all three. This one is really different to the other two, which are quite similar both in texture and taste. The only difference for me was the crackling. This one, it stands out of the three and offers something a little different with that tartiness of the apple source. For me, Banner Crust is the winner.”

Roses The Bakers, 5 Brooklands Avenue, Sheffield, S10 4GAplaceholder image
Roses The Bakers, 5 Brooklands Avenue, Sheffield, S10 4GA | Local Library

Personally I decided to choose Roses The Bakers’ hot roast pork sandwich.

It was perfectly ensconced in that fluffy yet structurally sound bread cake. When I went in to buy this, the pork loin had just finished cooking, it was fresh, succulent, juicy and flavoursome. All in all, a perfect example of a solid roast pork sandwich.

We tried out three examples of roast pork sandwiches. Each one was not only a tasty delight but delivered much appreciated moments of flavour in their own way. It was difficult to pick between them as they all had their merits.

But what we’d like to know is, where is your favourite place to go for a pork sandwich in Sheffield?

Share your answers in the comments or send them to me in an email and we’ll tot up the most popular according to Sheffield folks.

We may even pay a visit to the top-ranked spot!

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice