Sheffield Children's Hospital commended after practices meant 'just one' patient infected in HIV blood scandal

Chairman Sir Brian Langstaff called the solitary infection “one too many”

Sheffield Children’s Hospital was commended when a public inquiry into the infected blood scandal found good practices meant just one patient was treated with contaminated blood - but it was still called “one too many.”

The findings from “the biggest treatment disaster in NHS history” were published yesterday (May 20) over how more than 30,000 people were infected with HIV and Hepatitis from contaminated blood, leading to around 3,000 deaths.

Chairman of the infected blood inquiry Sir Brian Langstaff (centre) mentioned Sheffield Children's Hospital during today's findings, saying its practices led to just one patient being infected compared to the severe failings at other hospitals. Photo by Jeff Moore/PA Wireplaceholder image
Chairman of the infected blood inquiry Sir Brian Langstaff (centre) mentioned Sheffield Children's Hospital during today's findings, saying its practices led to just one patient being infected compared to the severe failings at other hospitals. Photo by Jeff Moore/PA Wire | Jeff Moore/PA Wire

Further, the Government and senior NHS officials were accused of a cover up, with chairman Sir Brian Langstaff saying people "put their faith in doctors and in the government... and their trust was betrayed.”

The findings include how, in the 1970s, whole batches of a then-new treatment for people with bleeding disorders like haemophilia made from donated blood plasma were contaminated.

Some of the treatments were bought and imported from the US using blood from prison inmates and drug-users.

Amid the findings, Sheffield Children’s Hospital was highlighted when good practices meant “only one” patient was infected with HIV at the height of the scandal, compared to the severe failings of other hospitals.

Sheffield Children’s Hospital was compared to Alder Hey Children’s Hospital over how its practices led to just one infection during the scandal. A Google Maps image of Sheffield Children's Hospital.placeholder image
Sheffield Children’s Hospital was compared to Alder Hey Children’s Hospital over how its practices led to just one infection during the scandal. A Google Maps image of Sheffield Children's Hospital.

Sir Brian Langstaff said: “On either side of the Pennines, Alder Hey and Sheffield Children's Hospital treated children with bleeding disorders at the height of the AIDS crisis.

“Alder Hey almost exclusively treated its children with large pool commercial concentrates. Utterly inappropriate. Almost all children were infected with AIDS.

"By contrast at Sheffield, Professor John Lilleyman sought to minimise exposure to multiple donors via cryoprecipitate [a treatment involving frozen plasma in small volumes]. There was one infection with HIV at Sheffield Children’s Hospital.

“It's still one too many but it's illustrative of the fact that different treatment practices by hemophiliac clinicians could have substantially reduced the number of infections."

The findings said victims of the scandal were failed “not once, but repeatedly,” with too little testing to reduce the risk of infecting patients with viruses, and blood was accepted from high-risk groups of donors such as prisoners. Documents were destroyed and Sir Langstaff accused authorities of “downright deception.”

Sir Brian said: "This disaster was not an accident. The infections happened because those in authority - doctors, the blood services and successive governments - did not put patient safety first."

In 2022, the government made interim payments of £100,000 each to around 4,000 surviving victims and some bereaved partners. Sir Langstaff said compensation should also be offered to the children and parents of those infected.

PM Rishi Sunak is expected to make a formal apology later this week.

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice