Family want to meet government minister over concerns after Sheffield hospital death of son, five
Recommendations made in report into tragic death of boy, aged five, at hospital
A grieving family say they still want answers after an investigation returned a string of recommendations after the death of their son at Sheffield Children’s Hospital.
Ayaan Rashid died aged just five in March 2023. He had suffered from a condition called Hace 1, and became unwell at home before being admitted to hospital with a lower respiratory tract infection.


He died from what was known as overwhelming disseminated adenovirus bronchopneumonia.
The report, shown to The Star, which was commissioned by Sheffield Children's NHS Foundation Trust, found that aspects of Ayaan's care did not meet expected standards, and made 22 recommendations, although it recognised some actions might have marginally increased his chance of survival.
Four recommendations were national, and 18 to the hospital.
Now his family want to take the matter to the Government’s minster for patient safety, Dr Zubir Ahmed, because they feel the final report has been ‘sanitised’ and not gone as far as they would have liked.


They said the final report, by Niche Health and Social Care Consulting, did not take into account the family’s feedback which they had given following a draft report which they had previously been shown.
The family were given a draft report into his death in January 2025, which considered 736 complaint points submitted by Ayaan's family into the care he received. The investigation had upheld 307 and partly upheld 171.
Investigators said their final report was shaped by feedback from the family on the draft report, but the family does not feel it has taken that feedback into account.


The family discussed the report in a 30 minute meeting with hospital bosses last week, which they added was also attended by their MP, Sheffield Central MP Abtisam Mohamed.
They are also concerned that the full report would not be published in the public arena by the trust.
Ayaan’s dad, Haroon Rashid, said: “All we want as a family is to ensure no other child suffers like Ayaan did, and that meaningful lessons are finally learned.
“We feel like hundreds of comments that we made in a large document have just been thrown in the bin.
“It feels like there has been no accountability, and this has not answered all our questions..”
Haroon feels the most strongly about two of the recommendations.
The first of those is a recommendation that the trust makes sure it keeps contemporaneous records, after the review found the trust’s record-keeping was not always comprehensive, contemporaneous and did not identify individual responsibilities and accountabilities of the clinicians involved. The report stated that the process of recording conversations with parents was variable, and the assimilation of records was not robust.
The second was a recommendation that if a child needed intensive care, and no intensive care unit bed was available, the intensive care should be carried out on the general ward on which they were currently being cared for until a specialist bed becomes available.
We recognise the profound impact that the loss of a child has on their family, friends and those who cared for them
Dr Jeff Perring, Executive Medical Director at Sheffield Children’s NHS Foundation Trust: “Sheffield Children’s is fully committed to learning from all complaint investigations into the care and experience of children, young people and their families.
“We recognise the profound impact that the loss of a child has on their family, friends and those who cared for them.
“We appreciate how difficult independent reports, such as this, are for the families affected. We understand the importance of working together to ensure that the lessons learned are implemented in our everyday care for children and young people.”
